Relating to: eliminating the personal property tax and making an appropriation.

hist137624 Read a second time.

POINT OF ORDER

Senator LeMahieu raised the point of order that Senate Substitute Amendment 1 to Assembly Bill 191 was not germane, pursuant to Senate Rule 50 (6)(b)4.

The Chair ruled the point of order well taken.

Senator Erpenbach appealed the ruling of the Chair.

hist137613 The question was: Shall the Decision of the Chair stand as the judgment of the Senate?

The ayes and noes were required and the vote was: ayes, 12; noes, 20; absent or not voting, 1; as follows:

Ayes - Senators Agard, Bewley, Carpenter, Erpenbach, Johnson, Larson, Pfaff, Ringhand, Roys, Smith, L. Taylor and Wirch - 12.

Noes - Senators Ballweg, Bernier, Bradley, Cowles, Darling, Felzkowski, Feyen, Jacque, Jagler, Kapenga, Kooyenga, LeMahieu, Marklein, Nass, Petrowski, Stafsholt, Stroebel, Testin, Wanggaard and Wimberger - 20.

Absent or not voting - Senator Roth - 1.

The Decision of the Chair stands as the judgment of the Senate.

hist137615 Senator LeMahieu moved that Senate Amendment 1 to Assembly Bill 191 be rejected.

The question was: Rejection of Senate Amendment 1 to Assembly Bill 191?

Rejected.

hist137616 Senator LeMahieu moved that Senate Amendment 2 to Assembly Bill 191 be rejected.

The question was: Rejection of Senate Amendment 2 to Assembly Bill 191?

The ayes and noes were demanded and the vote was: ayes, 20; noes, 12; absent or not voting, 1; as follows:

Ayes - Senators Ballweg, Bernier, Bradley, Cowles, Darling, Felzkowski, Feyen, Jacque, Jagler, Kapenga, Kooyenga, LeMahieu, Marklein, Nass, Petrowski, Stafsholt, Stroebel, Testin, Wanggaard and Wimberger - 20.

Noes - Senators Agard, Bewley, Carpenter, Erpenbach, Johnson, Larson, Pfaff, Ringhand, Roys, Smith, L. Taylor and Wirch - 12.

Absent or not voting - Senator Roth - 1.

Rejected.

hist137617 Ordered to a third reading.

hist137618 Senator LeMahieu, with unanimous consent, asked that the rules be suspended and the bill be given its third reading.

hist137622 Assembly Bill 191

Read a third time.

The question was: Concurrence of Assembly Bill 191?

The ayes and noes were demanded and the vote was: ayes, 20; noes, 12; absent or not voting, 1; as follows:

Ayes - Senators Ballweg, Bernier, Bradley, Cowles, Darling, Felzkowski, Feyen, Jacque, Jagler, Kapenga, Kooyenga, LeMahieu, Marklein, Nass, Petrowski, Stafsholt, Stroebel, Testin, Wanggaard and Wimberger - 20.