LRB-3546/2
GMM:kaf:jf
1997 - 1998 LEGISLATURE
November 11, 1997 - Introduced by
Joint Legislative Council.
AB600,2,7
1An Act to repeal 48.837 (1m) and 48.837 (2) (d);
to renumber and amend 48.38
2(4) (d);
to consolidate, renumber and amend 48.837 (6) (b) (intro.), 1. and 2.;
3to amend 48.427 (6) (a), 48.46 (1), 48.64 (1m), 48.835 (2), 48.837 (4) (a), 48.93
4(1d), 48.988 (8) (a), 115.92 (1), 948.24 (1) (a) and 948.24 (1) (c);
to repeal and
5recreate 48.81; and
to create 48.38 (4) (d) 1., 2. and 3., 48.422 (7) (bm), 48.434,
648.46 (1m), 48.825, 48.913 and 115.355 of the statutes;
relating to: the
7placement of a child with a relative for adoption and application of the
8interstate compact on the placement of children; the time by which a juvenile
9court must hold a hearing on a petition for adoptive placement of a child with
10a nonrelative and a petition to terminate parental rights that is filed with a
11petition for adoptive placement; removal of a child from a foster home,
12treatment foster home or group home for the purpose of placing the child by an
13agency for adoption; education about adoption and school age parents
14programs; who may be adopted; the documentation required in a permanency
1plan for preadoptive placement of a child in foster care or treatment foster care
2under a voluntary agreement; payments by an adoptive or proposed adoptive
3parent for the expenses of a birth parent or child; the release of identifying
4information by an agency that placed a child for adoption or that was appointed
5guardian of a child who was adopted; advertising related to adoption; the time
6by which a petition for a rehearing on the ground of new evidence must be filed
7in a juvenile court proceeding; and providing a penalty.
Analysis by the Legislative Reference Bureau
This bill is explained in the Notes provided by the joint legislative council in
the bill.
For further information see the state and local fiscal estimate, which will be
printed as an appendix to this bill.
The people of the state of Wisconsin, represented in senate and assembly, do
enact as follows:
Prefatory note: This bill was prepared for the joint legislative council's special
committee on adoption laws.
Payment of Birth Parents' Expenses by Proposed Adoptive Parents
1. Payments by proposed adoptive parents which are allowed. Current law
contains the following provisions relating to payments made by adoptive or proposed
adoptive parents to or on behalf of a birth parent or child:
a. Section 948.24, stats., which prohibits any person from taking any of the
following actions:
(1) Placing or agreeing to place his or her child for adoption for anything exceeding
the actual cost of the hospital and medical expenses of the mother and the child incurred
in connection with the child's birth and of the legal and other services rendered in
connection with the adoption.
(2) Soliciting, negotiating or arranging the placement of a child for adoption for
anything of value, except under s. 48.833, stats., relating to placement of children for
adoption by the department of health and family services (DHFS), county departments
of human services or social services (county departments) and licensed adoption agencies.
(3) Giving anything exceeding the actual cost of the hospital and medical expenses
of the mother and the child incurred in connection with the child's birth and of the legal
and other services rendered in connection with the adoption in order to receive a child for
adoption.
The criminal prohibitions described above do not apply to adoptive placements
under s. 48.839, stats., relating to foreign adoptions. Anyone who takes any of the
prohibited actions is guilty of a Class D felony, which is punishable by a fine not to exceed
$10,000 or imprisonment not to exceed 5 years, or both.
b. Section 48.837 (2) (d), stats., which provides that the petition for adoptive
placement in an independent adoption by a nonrelative must include a report of all
transfers of anything of value made or agreed to be made by the proposed adoptive
parents or on their behalf in connection with the birth of the child, the placement of the
child with the proposed adoptive parents, the medical or hospital care received by the
child or by the child's mother in connection with the birth of the child and any other
expenses, including the estimated legal expenses, of either the child's parent or the
proposed adoptive parents.
c. Section 48.837 (7), stats., which provides that the proposed adoptive parents in
an independent adoption by a nonrelative must pay the cost of any investigation of the
proposed adoptive placement ordered by the juvenile court, according to a fee schedule
established by DHFS based on ability to pay. That section also provides that if the
adoption is completed, the proposed adoptive parents must pay the cost of any foster care
provided for the child.
According to adoption practitioners, courts assigned to exercise jurisdiction under
the children's code (juvenile courts) throughout the state differ in the types of payments
which proposed adoptive parents are permitted to make on behalf of a birth parent.
The bill creates several new provisions regarding payments made by or on behalf
of adoptive or proposed adoptive parents to or on behalf of a birth parent of the child, an
alleged or presumed father of the child or the child, which are described below. These
provisions do not apply to foreign adoptions or to the adoption of a child by a relative of
the child. A criminal penalty, however, could apply in a relative adoption if it were shown
that a person placed or agreed to place his or her child for adoption with a relative for
anything other than the payments authorized or that a relative of a child gave anything
other than the payments authorized in order to receive the child for adoption.
The bill permits the proposed adoptive parents of a child, or a person acting on
behalf of the proposed adoptive parents, to pay the actual cost of any of the following:
a. Preadoptive counseling for a birth parent of the child or an alleged or presumed
father of the child.
b. Post-adoptive counseling for a birth parent of the child or an alleged or
presumed father of the child.
c. Maternity clothes for the child's birth mother, not to exceed a reasonable amount.
d. Local transportation expenses of a birth parent of the child that are related to
the pregnancy or adoption.
e. Services provided by a licensed child welfare agency in connection with the
adoption.
f. Medical and hospital care received by the child's birth mother in connection with
the pregnancy or birth of the child.
g. Medical and hospital care received by the child.
h. Legal and other services received by a birth parent of the child, an alleged or
presumed father of the child or the child in connection with the adoption.
i. Living expenses of the child's birth mother, in an amount not to exceed $1,000,
if payment of the living expenses by the proposed adoptive parents or a person acting on
their behalf is necessary to protect the health and welfare of the birth mother or the fetus.
j. Any investigation of the proposed adoptive home ordered by the juvenile court,
according to a fee schedule established by DHFS based on ability to pay.
k. If the adoption is completed, the cost of any foster care provided for the child.
L. Birthing classes.
m. A gift to the child's birth mother from the proposed adoptive parents, of no
greater than $50 in value.
2. Payment of expenses when the birth parent is residing in another state. The bill
also permits, in addition to the permissible payments described above, the proposed
adoptive parents of a child to pay an expense of a birth parent of the child or of an alleged
or presumed father of the child if the birth parent or the alleged or presumed father was
residing in another state when the payment was made and when the expense was
incurred and if all of the following apply:
a. The child was placed for adoption in this state in accordance with the interstate
compact on the placement of children (ICPC).
b. The state in which the birth parent or the alleged or presumed father was
residing when the payment was made permits the payment of that expense by the
proposed adoptive parents of the child.
c. The proposed adoptive parents provide all of the following to the juvenile court;
(1) A listing of the payments the proposed adoptive parents of the child or a person
acting on their behalf have made or have agreed to make to or on behalf of the birth parent
or the alleged or presumed father.
(2) A copy of the statutory provisions of the state in which the birth parent or the
alleged or presumed father was residing when those payments were made that permit
those payments to be made by the proposed adoptive parents of the child.
(3) A copy of all orders entered in the state in which the birth parent or the alleged
or presumed father was residing when those payments were made that relate to the
payment of expenses of the birth parent or the alleged or presumed father by the proposed
adoptive parents or a person acting on their behalf.
The information listed above must be provided to the juvenile court as follows:
a. If the parental rights of either parent of the child are terminated in this state,
the information must be provided at the hearing on the termination of parental rights
(TPR) petition.
b. If the parental rights of both parents of the child are terminated in another state
and the child is placed for adoption with a nonrelative in an independent adoptive
placement, the information must be provided with the petition for adoptive placement.
c. If the parental rights of both parents of the child have been terminated in
another state and the child is placed for adoption by an agency, the information must be
provided with the petition for adoption.
3. Methods by which payments may be made. The bill requires a payment by or
on behalf of a proposed adoptive parent to be made either directly to the provider of a good
or service or to the birth parent of the child or an alleged or presumed father of the child
as reimbursement of amounts previously paid by the birth parent or the alleged or
presumed father if documentation is provided showing that the birth parent or the
alleged or presumed father has made the previous payment.
4. Payments by proposed adoptive parents which are prohibited. The bill prohibits
the proposed adoptive parents of a child or a person acting on their behalf from making
any payments to or on behalf of a birth parent of the child, an alleged or presumed father
of the child or the child other than those listed as allowed under items 2. and 3., above.
5. Payments made after finalization of adoption. The bill permits the proposed
adoptive parents of a child or a person acting on their behalf to make any of the allowable
payments after finalization of the adoption (at which point the proposed adoptive parents
become "adoptive parents"), if the payments are included in the report to the juvenile
court described below or an amendment to the report which is filed with the juvenile
court.
6. Report regarding payments must be submitted to and reviewed by the juvenile
court. Under current law, a petition for independent adoptive placement with a
nonrelative must include any agreement between the birth parent and the proposed
adoptive parent that relates to the payment of any adoption-related expenses. The
juvenile court must review the agreement to determine whether any conditions specified
in the agreement are coercive to the birth parent. If the juvenile court finds coercion, the
juvenile court must dismiss the petition or amend the agreement to delete any coercive
conditions, if the parties agree to the amendment.
Also under current law, a petition for independent adoptive placement with a
nonrelative must include a report of all transfers of value related to the adoption made
or agreed to be made by the proposed adoptive parents or on their behalf. Current law,
however, does not specifically require the juvenile court to review the report or to take any
action if the juvenile court finds that improper payments have been or may be made.
Under current law, in an agency adoption, there is
no requirement that any
agreement or report regarding adoption-related payments be submitted to or reviewed
by the juvenile court.
The bill does all of the following:
a. For an agency adoption, requires the submission of the same information
regarding adoption-related payments and the same juvenile court review of that
information that is required for an independent adoptive placement with a nonrelative.
Specifically, the bill requires the juvenile court, at the hearing on a TPR petition which
is not filed with a petition for independent adoptive placement with a nonrelative, to
determine whether a proposed adoptive parent of a child who is not a relative of the child
has been identified. If a proposed adoptive parent has been identified, the juvenile court
must order the petitioner to submit a report of all adoption-related payments made by
or on behalf of the proposed adoptive parents to or on behalf of the birth parent of the
child, an alleged or presumed father of the child or the child. The juvenile court must
review that report to determine if any payments or agreement to make payments are
coercive to the birth parent or to an alleged or presumed father.
b. For agency adoptions and independent adoptions by a nonrelative, adds the
following items to the list of information which must be included in the report of
adoption-related payments made or agreed to be made by or on behalf of the proposed
adoptive parents:
(1) Payments to or on behalf of the child.
(2) Payments to or on behalf of an alleged or presumed father of the child.
(3) Payments made in connection with the pregnancy of the birth mother.
c. For agency adoptions and independent adoptions by a nonrelative, requires the
juvenile court to determine whether any payments or agreement to make payments are
impermissible, in addition to the current requirement to determine whether any
payments or agreement to make payments are coercive to the birth parent.
d. For agency adoptions and independent adoptions by a nonrelative, if the
juvenile court finds that impermissible payments have been made, authorizes the
juvenile court to dismiss the TPR petition or petition for adoptive placement and refer the
matter to the district attorney for prosecution under s. 948.24 (1), stats., which provides
criminal penalties for making or receiving impermissible payments related to adoption.
e. For agency adoptions and independent adoptions by a nonrelative, changes the
grounds for finding coercion of the birth parent or of an alleged or presumed father of the
child as follows:
Current law provides that "[m]aking the payment of the birth parent's expenses that
are permitted under s. 948.24 (1) (a) or (c) conditional in any part upon transfer or
surrender of the child or the termination of parental rights or the finalization of the
adoption creates a rebuttable presumption of coercion" (emphasis added).
The bill changes this provision to read as follows:
"Making any payment to or on behalf of the birth parent of the child, an alleged or
presumed father of the child or the child conditional in any part upon transfer or
surrender of the child or finalization of the adoption creates a rebuttable presumption of
coercion" (emphasis added).
7. Criminal penalties for unauthorized placement for adoption. Current law sets
forth criminal penalties which apply to a person who makes any payments that are not
authorized under s. 948.24 (1) (c), stats., in order to receive a child for adoption or who
places or agrees to place a child for adoption in exchange for any payments that are not
authorized under s. 948.24 (1) (a), stats. Specifically, current law provides that whoever
does any of the following is guilty of a Class D felony:
a. Places or agrees to place his or her child for adoption for anything exceeding the
actual cost of the hospital and medical expenses of the mother and the child incurred in
connection with the child's birth, and of the legal and other services rendered in
connection with the adoption [s. 948.24 (1) (a), stats.].
b. In order to receive a child for adoption, gives anything exceeding the actual cost
of the hospital and medical expenses of the mother and the child incurred in connection
with the child's birth, and of the legal and other services rendered in connection with the
adoption [s. 948.24 (1) (c), stats.].
The penalty for a Class D felony is a fine not to exceed $10,000 or imprisonment
not to exceed 5 years, or both.
The bill amends the criminal provisions to correspond to the changes the bill makes
in the children's code regarding payments related to adoption. Thus, under the bill,
making or receiving any of the payments authorized by the bill is not grounds for criminal
prosecution.
Under current law and the bill the criminal provisions do not apply to the adoption
of a foreign child under s. 48.839, stats.
Release of Identifying Information by Agency to Adoptive Parents and Birth Parents
Under current law, all records and papers pertaining to an adoption proceeding
must be kept in a locked file and may not be disclosed except by order of the court for good
cause shown or under any of 6 exceptions set forth in the statutes. The 6 exceptions are
as follows:
1. Section 48.93 (1g), stats., which requires a juvenile court, at the time the juvenile
court enters an order granting an adoption, to provide the adoptive parents with a copy
of the child's medical records or other medical information pertaining to the child, after
deleting the names and addresses of the child's birth parents and the identity of any
provider of health care to the child or the child's birth parents.
2. Section 48.93 (1r), stats., which requires any agency that has placed a child for
adoption, at the request of an adoptive parent or of the adoptee, after the adoptee has
reached 18 years of age, to provide the requester with certain medical or genetic
information and nonidentifying social history information.