SB44,688,723
71.74
(13) (b) No action or proceeding whatsoever shall be brought against the
24state or the
treasurer thereof secretary of administration for the recovery, refund
, or
25credit of any income or surtaxes; except in case the
state treasurer secretary of
1administration shall neglect or refuse for a period of 60 days to refund any
2overpayment of any income or surtaxes certified, the taxpayer may maintain an
3action to collect the overpayment against the
treasurer secretary of administration 4so neglecting or refusing to refund such overpayment, without filing a claim for
5refund with
such treasurer the secretary of administration, provided that such
6action shall be commenced within one year after the certification of such
7overpayment.
SB44, s. 1586
8Section
1586. 71.74 (14) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,688,249
71.74
(14) Additional remedy to collect tax. The department may also
10proceed under s. 71.91 (5) for the collection of any additional assessment of income
11or franchise taxes or surtaxes, after notice thereof has been given under sub. (11) and
12before the same shall have become delinquent, when it has reasonable grounds to
13believe that the collection of such additional assessment will be jeopardized by delay.
14In such cases notice of the intention to so proceed shall be given by registered mail
15to the taxpayer, and the warrant of the department shall not issue if the taxpayer
16within 10 days after such notice furnishes a bond in such amount, not exceeding
17double the amount of the tax, and with such sureties as the department shall
18approve, conditioned upon the payment of so much of the additional taxes as shall
19finally be determined to be due, together with interest thereon as provided by s. 71.82
20(1) (a). Nothing in this subsection shall affect the review of additional assessments
21provided by ss. 71.88 (1) (a) and (2) (a), 71.89 (2), 73.01
, and 73.015, and any amounts
22collected under this subsection shall be deposited with the
state treasurer secretary
23of administration and disbursed after final determination of the taxes as are
24amounts deposited under s. 71.90 (2).
SB44, s. 1587
25Section
1587. 71.80 (1) (e) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,689,4
171.80
(1) (e) Representatives of the department directed by it to accept
2payment of income or franchise taxes shall file bonds with the
state treasurer 3secretary of administration in such amount and with such sureties as the state
4treasurer shall direct and approve.
SB44, s. 1588
5Section
1588. 71.80 (16) (b) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,689,256
71.80
(16) (b) A construction contractor required to file a surety bond under par.
7(a) may, in lieu of such requirement, but subject to approval by the department,
8deposit with the
state treasurer secretary of administration an amount of cash equal
9to the face of the bond that would otherwise be required. If an offer to deposit is made
, 10the department shall issue a certificate to the
state treasurer secretary of
11administration authorizing said
treasurer secretary to accept payment of such
12moneys and to give his or her receipt therefor. A copy of such certificate shall be
13mailed to the contractor who shall, within the time fixed by the department, pay such
14amount to
said treasurer the secretary of administration. A copy of the receipt of the
15state treasurer secretary of administration shall be filed with the department. Upon
16final determination by the department of such contractor's liability for state income
17or franchise taxes, required unemployment insurance contributions, sales and use
18taxes
, and income taxes withheld from wages of employees, interest and penalties,
19by reason of such contract or contracts, the department shall certify to the
state
20treasurer secretary of administration the amount of taxes, penalties
, and interest as
21finally determined, shall instruct the
treasurer
secretary of administration as to the
22proper distribution of such amount, and shall state the amount, if any, to be refunded
23to such contractor. The
state treasurer secretary of administration shall make the
24payments directed by such certificate within 30 days after receipt thereof. Amounts
25refunded to the contractor shall be without interest.
SB44, s. 1589
1Section
1589. 71.80 (17) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,690,52
71.80
(17) Tax receipts transmitted to
state treasurer the secretary of
3administration. Within 15 days after receipt of any income or franchise tax
4payments
, the department shall transmit the same to the
state treasurer secretary
5of administration.
SB44, s. 1590
6Section
1590. 71.82 (2) (d) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,690,247
71.82
(2) (d)
Withholding tax. Of the amounts required to be withheld any
8amount not deposited or paid over to the department within the time required shall
9be deemed delinquent and deposit reports or withholding reports filed after the due
10date shall be deemed late. Delinquent deposits or payments shall bear interest at
11the rate of 1.5% per month from the date deposits or payments are required under
12this section until deposited or paid over to the department. The department shall
13provide by rule for reduction of interest on delinquent deposits to 12% per year in
14stated instances wherein the secretary of revenue determines reduction fair and
15equitable. In the case of a timely filed deposit or withholding report, withheld taxes
16shall become delinquent if not deposited or paid over on or before the due date of the
17report. In the case of no report filed or a report filed late, withheld taxes shall become
18delinquent if not deposited or paid over by the due date of the report. In the case of
19an assessment under s. 71.83 (1) (b) 2., the amount assessed shall become delinquent
20if not paid on or before the first day of the calendar month following the calendar
21month in which the assessment becomes final, but if the assessment is contested
22before the
office of the commissioner of tax appeals
commission or in the courts, it
23shall become delinquent on the 30th day following the date on which the order or
24judgment representing final determination becomes final.
SB44, s. 1591
25Section
1591. 71.88 (2) (title) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,691,2
171.88
(2) (title)
Appeal to the Wisconsin office of the commissioner of tax
2appeals commission.
SB44, s. 1592
3Section
1592. 71.88 (2) (a) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,691,124
71.88
(2) (a)
Appeal of the department's redetermination of assessments and
5claims for refund. A person feeling aggrieved by the department's redetermination
6may appeal to the
office of the commissioner of tax appeals
commission by filing a
7petition with the clerk of the
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals 8as provided by law and the rules of practice promulgated by the
commission office
9of the commissioner of tax appeals. If a petition is not filed with the
commission office
10of the commissioner of tax appeals within the time provided in s. 73.01 or, except as
11provided in s. 71.75 (5), if no petition for redetermination is made within the time
12provided the assessment, refund, or denial of refund shall be final and conclusive.
SB44, s. 1593
13Section
1593. 71.88 (2) (b) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,691,2514
71.88
(2) (b)
Appeal of department's redetermination of credits. Any person
15aggrieved by the department of revenue's redetermination of a credit under s. 71.07
16(3m) or (6), 71.28 (1) or (2m) or 71.47 (1) or (2m) or subch. VIII or IX, except when the
17denial is based upon late filing of claim for credit or is based upon a redetermination
18under s. 71.55 (8) of rent constituting property taxes accrued as at arm's length, may
19appeal the redetermination to the
office of the commissioner of tax appeals
20commission by filing a petition with the
commission office of the commissioner of tax
21appeals within 60 days after the redetermination, as provided under s. 73.01 (5) with
22respect to income or franchise tax cases, and review of the
commission's decision
of
23the office of the commissioner of tax appeals may be had under s. 73.015. For appeals
24brought under this paragraph, the filing fee required under s. 73.01 (5) (a) does not
25apply.
SB44, s. 1594
1Section
1594. 71.89 (1) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,692,52
71.89
(1) If the taxpayer requests a hearing, the additional tax or overpayment
3shall not become due and payable until after hearing and determination of the tax
4by the
office of the commissioner of tax appeals
commission or disposition of the
5appeal pursuant to stipulation and order under ss. 73.01 (4) (a) and 73.03 (25).
SB44, s. 1595
6Section
1595. 71.89 (2) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,692,147
71.89
(2) No person against whom an assessment of income or franchise tax has
8been made shall be allowed in any action either as plaintiff or defendant or in any
9other proceeding to question such assessment unless the requirements of ss. 71.88
10and 71.90 (1) shall first have been complied with, and unless such person shall have
11made full disclosure under oath at the hearing before the
office of the commissioner
12of tax appeals
commission of any and all income that the person received. The
13requirement of full disclosure under this subsection may be waived by the
14department of revenue.
SB44, s. 1596
15Section
1596. 71.89 (3) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,692,1916
71.89
(3) As soon as the appellant shall have filed a petition with the
office of
17the commissioner of tax appeals
commission, all collection proceedings, except
18proceedings under s. 71.74 (14), shall be stayed until final determination of the
19appeal and any review thereof.
SB44, s. 1597
20Section
1597. 71.89 (4) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,693,321
71.89
(4) Any person who contests an assessment before the
office of the
22commissioner of tax appeals
commission or in court shall state in his or her petition
23or notice of appeal what portion if any of the tax is admitted to be legally assessable
24and correct. Within 5 days after notice by the department, the appellant shall pay
25to the department the whole amount of the admitted tax and such tax shall be
1appropriated in accordance with s. 25.20. Any such payment shall be considered an
2admission of the legality of the tax thus paid, and such tax so paid cannot be
3recovered in the pending appeal or in any other action or proceeding.
SB44, s. 1598
4Section
1598. 71.90 (2) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,693,245
71.90
(2) Deposit with the state treasurer. At any time while the petition is
6pending before the
office of the commissioner of tax appeals
commission or an appeal
7in regard to that petition is pending in a court, the taxpayer may offer to deposit the
8entire amount of the additional taxes, together with interest, with the state
9treasurer. If an offer to deposit is made, the department of revenue shall issue a
10certificate to the state treasurer authorizing the treasurer to accept payment of such
11taxes together with interest to the first day of the succeeding month and to give a
12receipt. A copy of the certificate shall be mailed to the taxpayer who shall pay the
13taxes and interest to the treasurer within 30 days. A copy of the receipt of the state
14treasurer shall be filed with the department. The department shall, upon final
15determination of the appeal, certify to the state treasurer the amount of the taxes as
16finally determined and direct the state treasurer to refund to the appellant any
17portion of such payment which has been found to have been improperly assessed,
18including interest. The state treasurer shall make the refunds directed by the
19certificate within 30 days after receipt. Taxes paid to the state treasurer under this
20subsection shall be subject to the interest provided by ss. 71.82 and 71.91 (1) (c) only
21to the extent of the interest accrued on the taxes prior to the first day of the month
22succeeding the application for hearing. Any portion of the amount deposited with the
23state treasurer which is refunded to the taxpayer shall bear interest at the rate of
249% per year during the time that the funds are on deposit.
SB44, s. 1599
1Section
1599
. 71.90 (2) of the statutes, as affected by 2003 Wisconsin Act ....
2(this act), is amended to read:
SB44,694,253
71.90
(2) Deposit with the state treasurer secretary of administration. At
4any time while the petition is pending before the office of the commissioner of tax
5appeals or an appeal in regard to that petition is pending in a court, the taxpayer may
6offer to deposit the entire amount of the additional taxes, together with interest, with
7the
state treasurer secretary of administration. If an offer to deposit is made, the
8department of revenue shall issue a certificate to the
state treasurer secretary of
9administration authorizing the
treasurer secretary to accept payment of such taxes
10together with interest to the first day of the succeeding month and to give a receipt.
11A copy of the certificate shall be mailed to the taxpayer who shall pay the taxes and
12interest to the
treasurer secretary of administration within 30 days. A copy of the
13receipt of the
state treasurer secretary of administration shall be filed with the
14department. The department shall, upon final determination of the appeal, certify
15to the
state treasurer secretary of administration the amount of the taxes as finally
16determined and direct the
state treasurer secretary of administration to refund to
17the appellant any portion of such payment which has been found to have been
18improperly assessed, including interest. The
state treasurer secretary of
19administration shall make the refunds directed by the certificate within 30 days
20after receipt. Taxes paid to the
state treasurer
secretary of administration under this
21subsection shall be subject to the interest provided by ss. 71.82 and 71.91 (1) (c) only
22to the extent of the interest accrued on the taxes prior to the first day of the month
23succeeding the application for hearing. Any portion of the amount deposited with the
24state treasurer secretary of administration which is refunded to the taxpayer shall
25bear interest at the rate of 9% per year during the time that the funds are on deposit.
SB44, s. 1600
1Section
1600. 71.91 (1) (b) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,695,142
71.91
(1) (b)
Withholding. Any amount not deposited or paid over to the
3department, or to the person that the department prescribes, within the time
4required shall be deemed delinquent and deposit reports or withholding reports filed
5after the due date shall be deemed late. In the case of a timely filed deposit or
6withholding report, withheld taxes shall become delinquent if not deposited or paid
7over on or before the due date of the report. In the case of no report filed or a report
8filed late, withheld taxes shall become delinquent if not deposited or paid over by the
9due date of the report. In the case of an assessment under s. 71.83 (1) (b) 2., the
10amount assessed shall become delinquent if not paid on or before the due date
11specified in the notice of deficiency, but if the assessment is contested before the
office
12of the commissioner of tax appeals
commission or in the courts, it shall become
13delinquent on the 30th day following the date on which the order or judgment
14representing final determination becomes final.
SB44, s. 1601
15Section
1601. 71.91 (1) (c) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,695,2216
71.91
(1) (c)
Contested income and franchise tax assessments. Any additional
17income or franchise tax assessment contested before the
office of the commissioner
18of tax appeals
commission or in the courts, which is finally determined to be correct,
19shall become delinquent if not paid on or before the 30th day following the date on
20which the order or judgment representing such final determination becomes final
21and conclusive. Any additional income or franchise tax assessment so contested
22shall be subject to s. 71.74 (14).
SB44, s. 1602
23Section
1602. 71.91 (5) (h) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,696,724
71.91
(5) (h) All fees and compensation of officials or other persons performing
25any act or functions required in carrying out this subchapter, except such as are by
1this subchapter to be paid to such officials or persons by the taxpayer, shall, upon
2presentation to the department of revenue of an itemized and verified statement of
3the amount due, be paid
by the state treasurer, upon audit by the department of
4administration on the certificate of the secretary of revenue
, by the secretary of
5administration and charged to the proper appropriation for the department of
6revenue. No public official shall be entitled to demand prepayment of any fee for the
7performance of any official act required in carrying out this subchapter.
SB44, s. 1603
8Section
1603. 71.91 (7) (e) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,696,179
71.91
(7) (e) Paragraphs (b) to (d) shall apply in any case in which the employer
10is the United States or any instrumentality thereof or this state or any municipality
11or other subordinate unit thereof except those provisions imposing a liability on the
12employer for failure to withhold or remit. But an amount equal to any amount
13withheld by any municipality or other subordinate unit of this state under this
14subsection and not remitted to the department as required by this subsection shall
15be retained by the
state treasurer secretary of administration from funds otherwise
16payable to any such municipality or subordinate unit, and transmitted instead to the
17department, upon certification by the secretary of revenue.
SB44, s. 1604
18Section
1604. 71.93 (1) (a) 4. of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,696,2119
71.93
(1) (a) 4. An amount that the department of workforce development may
20recover under s.
49.161, 49.195 (3)
, or 49.793,
or may collect under s. 49.147 (6) (cm), 21if the department of workforce development has certified the amount under s. 49.85.
SB44, s. 1605
22Section
1605
. 71.93 (1) (a) 4. of the statutes, as affected by 2003 Wisconsin Act
23.... (this act), is amended to read:
SB44,697,224
71.93
(1) (a) 4. An amount that the department of workforce development may
25recover under s. 49.161, 49.195 (3), or 49.793, or may collect under s.
49.147 (6) (cm)
149.1471 (3m), if the department of workforce development has certified the amount
2under s. 49.85.
SB44, s. 1606
3Section
1606. 71.93 (1) (a) 5. of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,697,54
71.93
(1) (a) 5. An amount owed to the department of corrections under s.
5304.073 (2) or 304.074 (2).
SB44, s. 1607
6Section
1607. 72.24 of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,697,10
772.24 Refunding. Whenever any amount has been paid in excess of the tax
8determined, the
state treasurer secretary of administration, upon certification by
9the department or circuit court, shall refund the excess to the payor or other person
10entitled thereto.
SB44, s. 1608
11Section
1608. Chapter 73 (title) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,697,1512
CHAPTER 73
13office of the commissioner
14
of TAX APPEALS
COMMISSION
15 AND DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE
SB44, s. 1609
16Section
1609. 73.01 (title) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,697,17
1773.01 (title)
Tax Office of the commissioner of tax appeals commission
.
SB44, s. 1610
18Section
1610. 73.01 (1) (a) of the statutes is repealed.
SB44, s. 1611
19Section
1611. 73.01 (1) (bm) of the statutes is created to read:
SB44,697,2220
73.01
(1) (bm) "Tax appeals commissioner" means the commissioner of the
21office of the commissioner of tax appeals, as appointed under ss. 15.06 (1) (bm) and
2215.105 (1m).
SB44, s. 1612
23Section
1612. 73.01 (2) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,698,3
173.01
(2) Employees. The
chairperson of the commission tax appeals
2commissioner may appoint, under the classified service, such employees for the
3commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals as are necessary.
SB44, s. 1613
4Section
1613. 73.01 (3) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,698,115
73.01
(3) Hearings and reports. (a) The time and place of meetings and
6hearings of the
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals shall be
7designated by the
chairperson tax appeals commissioner. Rooms for hearings
8outside the city of Madison shall be provided under s. 73.07. All hearings held in
9Milwaukee shall be held in the southeast district office of the department of natural
10resources. The
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals shall maintain
11permanent hearing rooms in Madison.
SB44,698,2212
(b) The
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals shall provide for
13the publication of such of its reports, decisions and opinions as are of public interest
14in such form as it deems best adapted for public convenience and use. Such
15publications shall constitute the official reports of the
commission office of the
16commissioner of tax appeals and shall be made available for sale and distribution to
17the public under ch. 35. In addition to any report submitted under s. 15.06 (7), the
18commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals shall make additional reports
19to the governor or the legislature as they request. The
commission office of the
20commissioner of tax appeals shall submit a report requested by the legislature to the
21chief clerk of each house of the legislature, for distribution to the legislature under
22s. 13.172 (2).
SB44, s. 1614
23Section
1614. 73.01 (4) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,699,1924
73.01
(4) Powers and duties defined. (a) Subject to the provisions for judicial
25review contained in s. 73.015, the
commission office of the commissioner of tax
1appeals shall be the final authority for the hearing and determination of all questions
2of law and fact arising under sub. (5) and s. 72.86 (4), 1985 stats., and ss. 70.38 (4)
3(a), 70.397, 70.64, and 70.995 (8), s. 76.38 (12) (a), 1993 stats., ss. 76.39 (4) (c), 76.48
4(6), 76.91, 77.26 (3), 77.59 (6) (b), 78.01, 78.22, 78.40, 78.555, 139.02, 139.03, 139.06,
5139.31, 139.315, 139.33, 139.76, 139.78, 341.405, and 341.45, subch. XIV of ch. 71,
6and subch. VII of ch. 77. Whenever with respect to a pending appeal there is filed
7with the
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals a stipulation signed
8by the department of revenue and the adverse party, under s. 73.03 (25), or the
9department of transportation and the adverse party agreeing to an affirmance,
10modification, or reversal of the department of revenue's or department of
11transportation's position with respect to some or all of the issues raised in the appeal,
12the
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals shall enter an order
13affirming or modifying in whole or in part, or canceling the assessment appealed
14from, or allowing in whole or in part or denying the petitioner's refund claim, as the
15case may be, pursuant to and in accordance with the stipulation filed. No
16responsibility shall devolve upon the
commission
office of the commissioner of tax
17appeals, respecting the signing of an order of dismissal as to any pending appeal
18settled by the department of revenue or the department of transportation without
19the approval of the
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals.
SB44,700,320
(am) Whenever it appears to the
commission office of the commissioner of tax
21appeals or
, in respect to hearings conducted by one commissioner, to that
22commissioner to a person assigned to hear a matter under this section that
23proceedings have been instituted or maintained by the taxpayer primarily for delay
24or that the taxpayer's position in those proceedings is frivolous or groundless, the
25commission or commissioner office of the commissioner of tax appeals or the tax
1appeals commissioner may assess the taxpayer an amount not to exceed $1,000 at
2the same time that the deficiency is assessed. Those damages shall be paid upon
3notice from the department of revenue and shall be collected as a part of the tax.
SB44,700,184
(b) Any matter required to be heard by the
commission
office of the
5commissioner of tax appeals may be heard by
any member of the commission or its 6the tax appeals commissioner or by a hearing examiner and reported to the
office of
7the commissioner of tax appeals, and hearings of matters pending before it shall be
8assigned to
members of the commission or its the tax appeals commissioner or to a 9hearing examiner by the
chairperson tax appeals commissioner.
Unless a majority
10of the commission decides that the full commission should decide a case, cases other
11than small claims cases shall be decided by a panel of 3 members assigned by the
12chairperson prior to the hearing. If the parties have agreed to an oral decision, the
13member or members person conducting the hearing may render an oral decision.
14Hearings shall be open to the public and all proceedings shall be conducted in
15accordance with rules of practice and procedure prescribed by the
commission office
16of the commissioner of tax appeals. Small claims cases shall be decided by
one
17commissioner the tax appeals commissioner or by a hearing examiner, as assigned
18by the
chairperson tax appeals commissioner prior to the hearing.
SB44,701,219
(bn) The parties to any matter required to be heard and decided by the
20commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals, except appeals arising under
21s. 70.64 or ch. 76, may consent in writing that the
chairperson or any member of the
22commission person assigned to hear the matter may render an oral decision, and that
23the parties waive the right to appeal such decision. Such oral decision shall not be
24binding upon the department, as to statutory construction, in a subsequent matter.
1Provisions of this section, s. 73.015 or ch. 227 in conflict herewith shall not apply to
2decisions rendered under this paragraph.
SB44,701,213
(c) The
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals shall, upon the
4request of any party to a matter pending before it or of any officer of the state
5government or upon its own motion order that all proceedings in a matter pending
6before it be recorded, and the expense thereof shall be paid by the state out of the
7appropriation for the
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals. The
8commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals may supply copies of the
9transcript of those recordings to anyone requesting them, at the expense of the
10person making such request. All moneys received by the
commission office of the
11commissioner of tax appeals from the sale of transcripts of those recordings shall be
12paid into the state treasury within one week after receipt. If no party to a matter
13pending before the
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals requests
14that the proceedings held with respect thereto be recorded, and the
commission office
15of the commissioner of tax appeals does not so order upon its own motion, all parties
16shall be deemed to have waived all rights of appeal to the courts upon questions as
17to the admission or exclusion of evidence or as to whether a finding of the
commission 18office of the commissioner of tax appeals is warranted by the evidence. The right of
19appeal upon questions of law raised by the pleadings or by facts stipulated or shown
20by the findings of the
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals is not
21waived.
SB44,702,1422
(d)
Any member of the commission The tax appeals commissioner or any
23employee of the
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals, designated in
24writing for the purpose by the
chairperson tax appeals commissioner, may
25administer oaths, and
any member of the commission
the tax appeals commissioner
1or any hearing examiner designated by the tax appeals commissioner may summon
2and examine witnesses and require by subpoena the production of all returns, books,
3papers, documents, correspondence and other evidence pertaining to the matter
4under inquiry, at any designated place of hearing and may require the taking of a
5deposition before any person competent to administer oaths, either within or without
6the state, upon notice to the interested party in like manner that depositions of
7witnesses are taken in civil actions pending in the circuit court. Any party to a matter
8pending before the
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals may
9summon witnesses or require the production of papers in the same manner as
10witnesses are summoned or papers required to be produced in civil actions in the
11circuit court. Any person summoned or whose deposition is taken shall receive the
12same fees and mileage as would be allowed in a civil action pending in the circuit
13court, and the expense thereof shall be paid by the person summoning such witness
14or causing the deposition to be taken.
SB44,703,215
(dn) In connection with the hearing of any matter required to be heard and
16decided by the
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals, except appeals
17arising under s. 70.64 or ch. 76, the
chairperson or any member of the commission 18person assigned to hear the matter may, with the consent of the parties, render an
19oral decision. In small claims cases, the
presiding commissioner person assigned to
20hear the matter may, without consent of the parties, either render an oral decision
21at the close of the hearing or provide a written decision to all parties within 2 weeks
22after the hearing. Decisions in small claims cases are not precedents. Any party may
23appeal such oral decision as provided in s. 73.015. Oral decisions constitute notice
24for purposes of determining the time in which appeals may be taken. Provisions of
1this section or ch. 227 in conflict with this paragraph do not apply to decisions
2rendered under this paragraph.
SB44,703,133
(e) Except as provided in par. (dn), the
commission
office of the commissioner
4of tax appeals in each case heard by it shall, irrespective of ch. 227, make a decision
5in writing accompanied by findings of fact and conclusions of law. The
commission 6office of the commissioner of tax appeals may issue an opinion in writing in addition
7to its findings of fact and decision. The decision or order of the
commission office of
8the commissioner of tax appeals shall become final and shall be binding upon the
9petitioner and upon the department of revenue for that case unless an appeal is
10taken from the decision or order of the
commission
office of the commissioner of tax
11appeals under s. 73.015. Except in respect to small claims decisions, if the
12commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals construes a statute adversely
13to the contention of the department of revenue:
SB44,703,2214
1. Except for hearings on ss. 341.405 and 341.45 and except as provided in subd.
152., the department of revenue shall be deemed to acquiesce in the construction so
16adopted unless the department of revenue seeks review of the order or decision of the
17commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals so construing the statute. For
18purposes of this subdivision, the department of revenue has sought review of the
19order or decision if it seeks review and later settles the case or withdraws its petition
20for review or if the merits of the case are for other reasons not determined by judicial
21review. The construction so acquiesced in shall thereafter be followed by the
22department of revenue.
SB44,704,823
2. Except for hearings on ss. 341.405 and 341.45, the department of revenue
24may choose not to appeal and to nonacquiesce in the decision or order by sending a
25notice of nonacquiescence to the clerk of the
commission office of the commissioner
1of tax appeals, to the revisor of statutes for publication in the Wisconsin
2administrative register and to the taxpayer or the taxpayer's representative before
3the time expires for seeking a review of the decision or order under s. 73.015. The
4effect of this action is that, although the decision or order is binding on the parties
5for the instant case, the
commission's conclusions of law, the rationale
, and
the 6construction of statutes in the instant case
, as determined by the office of the
7commissioner of tax appeals, are not binding upon or required to be followed by the
8department of revenue in other cases.
SB44,704,179
(f) All reports, findings, decisions and opinions of the
commission office of the
10commissioner of tax appeals, and all evidence received by the
commission office of
11the commissioner of tax appeals, including a transcript of any report of the
12proceedings, shall be open to the inspection of the public, except that the originals
13of books, documents, records, labels, diagrams, and other exhibits introduced in
14evidence before the
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals, may be
15withdrawn from the custody of the
commission office of the commissioner of tax
16appeals in such manner and upon such terms as the
commission office of the
17commissioner of tax appeals may, in its discretion, prescribe.
SB44,704,2218
(g) The
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals shall, in
19manufacturing property redeterminations under s. 70.995 for which a refund is due
20a taxpayer because of a reduction in value by the
commission office of the
21commissioner of tax appeals, include in its determination a finding of whether the
22reduction was due to false or incomplete information supplied by the taxpayer.
SB44,704,2523
(h) The
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals may extend any
24of its deadlines for persons designated in section
7508 (a) of the internal revenue code
25for the length of time specified in that section.
SB44,705,3
1(i) If the department of revenue assesses under s. 71.74 (9), the
commission 2office of the commissioner of tax appeals shall consolidate the appeals of that
3assessment.
SB44, s. 1615
4Section
1615. 73.01 (4m) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,705,105
73.01
(4m) Deadline for decisions. (a) The final decision or order of the
6commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals shall be issued within 90 days
7after the date on which the last document necessary to the decision of the matter is
8received or the date on which a hearing is closed, whichever is later, unless good
9cause is shown or unless the parties and the
commission office of the commissioner
10of tax appeals agree to an extension.
SB44,705,1511
(b) No
member of the commission, including the chairperson, or its hearing
12examiner
, including the tax appeals commissioner, may receive any salary unless he
13or she first executes an affidavit at the end of each salary period stating that he or
14she has complied with the deadlines in par. (a). The affidavit shall be presented to
15and filed with every official who certifies, in whole or in part, the salary.
SB44,705,1916
(c) If a
member of the commission, including the chairperson, or its hearing
17examiner
or the tax appeals commissioner is unable to comply with the deadline
18under par. (a), that person shall so certify in the record, and the period is then
19extended for one additional period not to exceed 90 days.
SB44, s. 1616
20Section
1616. 73.01 (5) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,707,1121
73.01
(5) Appeals to commission the office of the commissioner of tax
22appeals. (a) Any person who is aggrieved by a determination of the state board of
23assessors under s. 70.995 (8) or who has filed a petition for redetermination with the
24department of revenue and who is aggrieved by the redetermination of the
25department of revenue may, within 60 days of the determination of the state board
1of assessors or of the department of revenue or, in all other cases, within 60 days after
2the redetermination but not thereafter, file with the clerk of the
commission office
3of the commissioner of tax appeals a petition for review of the action of the
4department of revenue and the number of copies of the petition required by rule
5adopted by the
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals. Any person who
6is aggrieved by a determination of the department of transportation under s. 341.405
7or 341.45 may, within 30 days after the determination of the department of
8transportation, file with the clerk of the
commission
office of the commissioner of tax
9appeals a petition for review of the action of the department of transportation and
10the number of copies of the petition required by rule adopted by the
commission office
11of the commissioner of tax appeals. If a municipality appeals, its appeal shall set
12forth that the appeal has been authorized by an order or resolution of its governing
13body and the appeal shall be verified by a member of that governing body as
14pleadings in courts of record are verified. The clerk of the
commission office of the
15commissioner of tax appeals shall transmit one copy to the department of revenue,
16or to the department of transportation, and to each party. In the case of appeals from
17manufacturing property assessments, the person assessed shall be a party to a
18proceeding initiated by a municipality. At the time of filing the petition, the
19petitioner shall pay to the
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals a $25
20filing fee. The
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals shall deposit the
21fee in the general fund. Within 30 days after such transmission the department of
22revenue, except for petitions objecting to manufacturing property assessments, or
23the department of transportation, shall file with the clerk of the
commission office
24of the commissioner of tax appeals an original and the number of copies of an answer
25to the petition required by rule adopted by the
commission office of the commissioner
1of tax appeals and shall serve one copy on the petitioner or the petitioner's attorney
2or agent. Within 30 days after service of the answer, the petitioner may file and serve
3a reply in the same manner as the petition is filed. Any person entitled to be heard
4by the
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals under s. 76.38 (12) (a),
51993 stats., or s. 76.39 (4) (c), 76.48, or 76.91 may file a petition with the
commission 6office of the commissioner of tax appeals within the time and in the manner provided
7for the filing of petitions in income or franchise tax cases. Such papers may be served
8as a circuit court summons is served or by certified mail. For the purposes of this
9subsection, a petition for review is considered timely filed if mailed by certified mail
10in a properly addressed envelope, with postage duly prepaid, which envelope is
11postmarked before midnight of the last day for filing.
SB44,707,2512
(b) The petition shall set forth specifically the facts upon which the petitioner
13relies, together with a statement of the propositions of law involved, and shall be in
14such form as the
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals by rule
15designates. After an answer is filed as provided in par. (a), the matter shall be
16regarded as at issue and the
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals 17shall set it for hearing. At all times while said appeal is pending before the
18commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals, the petitioner shall keep the
19commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals informed as to the petitioner's
20residence. Upon the petitioner's failure to do so, the mailing by the
commission office
21of the commissioner of tax appeals of a notice of hearing, decision and order or other
22papers by registered mail to the petitioner's attorney or to the petitioner's
23last-known address shall constitute good and sufficient service. Petitions and
24answers may be amended under rules to be prescribed by the
commission office of
25the commissioner of tax appeals.
SB44, s. 1617
1Section
1617. 73.015 (title) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,708,3
273.015 (title)
Review of determination of the office of the commissioner
3of tax appeals commission.
SB44, s. 1618
4Section
1618. 73.015 (1) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,708,115
73.015
(1) This section shall provide the sole and exclusive remedy for review
6of any decision or order of the
office of the commissioner of tax appeals
commission 7and no person may contest, in any action or proceeding, any matter reviewable by
8the
commission office of the commissioner of tax appeals unless such person has first
9availed himself or herself of a hearing before the
commission office of the
10commissioner of tax appeals under s. 73.01 or has cross-appealed under s. 70.995 (8)
11(a).
SB44, s. 1619
12Section
1619. 73.015 (2) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,708,1813
73.015
(2) Any adverse determination of the
office of the commissioner of tax
14appeals
commission is subject to review in the manner provided in ch. 227. If the
15circuit court construes a statute adversely to the contention of the department of
16revenue, the department shall be deemed to acquiesce in the construction so adopted
17unless an appeal to the court of appeals is taken, and the construction so acquiesced
18in shall thereafter be followed by the department.
SB44, s. 1620
19Section
1620. 73.03 (2a) of the statutes is amended to read:
SB44,710,620
73.03
(2a) To prepare, have published and distribute to each property tax
21assessor and to others who so request assessment manuals. The manual shall
22discuss and illustrate accepted assessment methods, techniques and practices with
23a view to more nearly uniform and more consistent assessments of property at the
24local level. The manual shall be amended by the department from time to time to
25reflect advances in the science of assessment, court decisions concerning assessment
1practices, costs, and statistical and other information considered valuable to local
2assessors by the department. The manual shall incorporate standards for the
3assessment of all types of renewable energy resource systems used in this state as
4soon as such systems are used in sufficient numbers and sufficient data exists to
5allow the formulation of valid guidelines. The manual shall incorporate standards,
6which the department of revenue and the state historical society of Wisconsin shall
7develop, for the assessment of nonhistoric property in historic districts and for the
8assessment of historic property, including but not limited to property that is being
9preserved or restored; property that is subject to a protective easement, covenant or
10other restriction for historic preservation purposes; property that is listed in the
11national register of historic places in Wisconsin or in this state's register of historic
12places and property that is designated as a historic landmark and is subject to
13restrictions imposed by a municipality or by a landmarks commission. The manual
14shall incorporate general guidelines about ways to determine whether property is
15taxable in part under s. 70.1105 and examples of the ways that s. 70.1105 applies in
16specific situations.
The manual shall establish standards and procedures for the
17assessment of manufacturing property under s. 70.995. The manual shall state that
18assessors are required to comply with s. 70.32 (1g) and shall suggest procedures for
19doing so. The manual or a supplement to it shall specify per acre value guidelines
20for each municipality for various categories of agricultural land based on the income
21that could be generated from its estimated rental for agricultural use, as defined by
22rule, and capitalization rates established by rule. The manual shall include
23guidelines for classifying land as agricultural land, as defined in s. 70.32 (2) (c) 1. and
24guidelines for distinguishing between land and improvements to land. The cost of
25the development, preparation, publication and distribution of the manual and of
1revisions and amendments to it shall be borne by the assessors and requesters at an
2individual volume cost or a subscription cost as determined by the department. All
3receipts shall be credited to the appropriation under s. 20.566 (2) (hi). The
4department may provide free assessment manuals to other state agencies or
5exchange them at no cost with agencies of other states or of the federal government
6for similar information or publications.