Mr. Turnpaugh argues that because his original sentence was based on two convictions (one for prostitution and one for bail jumping), he is entitled to the maximum amount of $5,000 for both counts based on a single term of imprisonment.
However, we find that this argument belies the plain language of the statute. The statute provides for compensation of “$5,000 per year for the imprisonment” (emphasis added). Specifically, the statute contemplates compensation for “the,” singular, imprisonment. There is nothing in the statute that allows for multiple annual awards in excess of the $5,000 annual cap for a single imprisonment term based on multiple counts or charges. The most recent circuit court decision also supports this interpretation, given that the circuit court ordered the Claims Board, on remand, to determine an award to equitably compensate Mr. Turnpaugh for “his wrongful conviction.” See, Turnpaugh v. Claims Board, Slip Opinion Case No. 13-CV-789 Milwaukee County Circuit Court June 12, 2013. Because the circuit court decision uses the singular of the word “conviction,” and because Mr. Turnpaugh was imprisoned for a total of 60 days in relation to both counts, which made up his conviction, his award of compensation is for the conviction or imprisonment, not for each count on which he was convicted. In the same criminal proceeding, he received a sentence of 6 months imprisonment stayed, and was placed on probation for 6 months. The Claims Board finds that it is reasonable and rational to interpret the plain language of the statute as applying to only the single 60-day imprisonment. Despite the fact the Mr. Turnpaugh was convicted on two counts, the facts show that he was imprisoned only once, not twice. Therefore, based on the plain language of the statute, the court order, the potential untimeliness of this argument, and the equities, the Claims Board finds that Mr. Turnpaugh is not entitled to recover twice under the statute for his single 60-day term of imprisonment.
Finally, we would note that Mr. Turnpaugh makes passing reference to the fact that he served 12 months on probation. However, Mr. Turnpaugh did not present any argument as to why probation is the equivalent to imprisonment under the statute. The Claims Board believes that the claimant does have a minimum responsibility to at least explain a theory of recovery and carry some burden of going forward. However, there are no legal citations in his claim nor facts on the record to explain why the Claims Board should extend the term “imprisonment” to cover a period of probation. Moreover, existing law appears to run against the notion that probation is the automatic equivalent of imprisonment. See, e.g., State v. Eckola, 2001 WI App 295, 249 Wis. 2d 276, 638 N.W.2d 903. In the absence of any development of this argument, the Claims Board declines to equate imprisonment to probation. Even if such an argument had merit, the Claims Board also concludes that the equities support our decision to give compensation based solely on the 60 days of imprisonment, which was the time Mr. Turnpaugh spent in jail and on electronic monitoring. Based on the above calculations and reasoning, the Claims Board awards Mr. Turnpaugh $822.00 as an award for his wrongful conviction for his 60 days of imprisonment.
2. Attorney’s Fees
In his current claim on remand filed August 29, 2013, Mr. Turnpaugh requested $36,025.89 in attorney’s fees.
Based on the totality of the circumstances of this case, and the unique procedural and litigation history of this case that presented legal questions and issues of first impression to the court, the Claims Board agrees that the claimant is entitled to and shall be awarded the full amount of attorney’s fees, costs and disbursements requested in the amount of $36,025.89.
The Claims Board believes it is important to underscore the full award of the requested fees, costs and disbursements in this case is based on the specific and unique record of this case. The Claims Board is very mindful of the precedent such an award could set, and cautions that the Claims Board is not generally inclined to award the full amount of such requested fees for future cases. However, the Claims Board is aware of the significant litigation history unique to this case and the issues raised herein. That history and the balancing of the equities surrounding such history are the basis for this award. Such facts, history and equities are unlikely to exist in future cases.
CONCLUSION
In conclusion, the Claims Board awards Mr. Turnpaugh $822.00 as an award for his wrongful conviction for his 60 days of imprisonment, and $36,025.89 for his attorney’s fees costs and disbursements, for a total of $36,847.89.
Dated at Madison, Wisconsin this 25th day of November, 2013.
GREGORY D. MURRAY
Secretary, Representative of the Secretary of Administration
BRIAN HAGEDORN
Representative of the Governor
JOSEPH LEIBHAM
Senate Finance Committee
PATRICIA STRACHOTA
Assembly Finance Committee
_____________
Pursuant to Wis. Stats. 13.172 (2) and (3), attached is the list of agency reports received from executive branch and legislative service agencies for the month of November, 2013.
Board on Aging and Long Term Care
2011-2013 Biennial Report
Pursuant to 16.009 (2)(i), Wis. Stats.
Received on October 15, 2013.
Department of Administration – Division of Intergovernmental Relations
Wisconsin Office of Federal/State Relations Quarterly Report
Pursuant to 16.548, Wis. Stats.
Received on November 20, 2013.
Gathering Waters Conservancy
FY 2013 Report of Activities
Pursuant to 23.0955 (2)(b)5, Wis. Stats.
Received on November 1, 2013.
Government Accountability Board
Lobbyist Update through 11/5/2013
Pursuant to 13.685 (7), Wis. Stats.
Received on November 11, 2013.
Department of Natural Resources
Properties Purchased with Funds from the Knowles-Nelson Stewardship Program
Pursuant to 23.0916 (6), Wis. Stats.
Received on November 19, 2013.
Referred to the joint committee on Finance.
Health Insurance Risk-Sharing Plan Authority
2012 Annual Report
Pursuant to 149.43 (6), Wis. Stats.
Received on November 15, 2013.
Department of Natural Resources
2013-2015 Land Acquisition Estimates
Pursuant to 23.0913, Wis. Stats.
Received on November 15, 2013.
Referred to the joint committee on Finance.
WHA Information Center
2010-2012 Wisconsin Inpatient Hospital Quality Indicators Report
Pursuant 153.22, Wis. Stats.
Received on November 14, 2013.
Legislative Audit Bureau
Review of Level of Commitment for University of Wisconsin System Program Revenue Balances
Pursuant to 13.94 (t), Wis. Stats.
Received on November 15, 2013.
Department of Revenue
Wisconsin Lottery Quarterly Report
Pursuant to 565.37 (3), Wis. Stats.
Received on November 19, 2013.
Government Accountability Board
Lobbyist Update through 11/20/2013
Pursuant to 13.685 (7), Wis. Stats.
Received on November 20, 2013.
Wisconsin Technical College System
2011-2013 Biennial Report
Pursuant to 15.04 (1)(d), Wis. Stats.
Received on November 20, 2013.
University of Wisconsin System
2013 Legislated Accountability Report
Received on November 21, 2013.
Office of the State Treasurer
2011-2013 Biennial Report
Pursuant to 15.04 (1)(d), Wis. Stats.
Received on November 21, 2013
_____________
Motions Under Senate Rule 98 and Joint Rule 7 for the Month of November 2013
A certificate of congratulations by the Wisconsin Senate on the motion of Senator Vukmir, for ANEW Health Care Services, on the occasion of 30 years of outstanding service to the Milwaukee area.
A certificate of congratulations by the Wisconsin Senate on the motion of Senator Lazich, for Walter Bohrer and Hastings Air Energy Control, Incorporated, on the occasion of the company’s expanded and improved Experience Technology Center as well as the company’s commitment to service, community, and economic growth.
A certificate of commendations by the Wisconsin Senate on the motion of Senator Moulton, for the Stanley-Boyd Football team, on the occasion of being state champions in the 2013 WIAA Division V State Football Tournament and on a successful season.
A certificate of commendations by the Wisconsin Legislature on the motion of Senator Harsdorf, for Nicholas Bradish, on the occasion of earning and attaining the rank of the Eagle Scout Award.
A certificate of commendations by the Wisconsin Senate on the motion of Senator Risser, for Stuart Fass, on the occasion of earning and attaining the rank of the Eagle Scout Award.
