Assembly
Record of Committee Proceedings
Committee on Housing and Real Estate
Assembly Bill 568
Relating to: terminating a tenancy for criminal activity or drug-related criminal activity; disposition of personal property left in rental property by a trespasser; preexisting sprinkler ordinances that are stricter than the multifamily dwelling code; towing vehicles illegally parked on private property; terminating certain tenancies for breaches other than failure to pay rent; limitations on the authority of political subdivisions to regulate rental units, historic properties, and signs; prohibiting local governmental units from imposing real property purchase or residential real property occupancy requirements; creating a criminal penalty; and making an appropriation.
By Representatives R. Brooks and Allen; cosponsored by Senators Lasee and Stroebel.
December 04, 2015 Referred to Committee on Housing and Real Estate
December 10, 2015 Public Hearing Held
Present: (8) Representative Jagler; Representatives Allen, R. Brooks, Katsma, Murphy, Murtha, Young and Stuck.
Absent: (0) None.
Excused: (1) Representative Genrich.
Appearances For
· REP. ROB BROOKS - 60TH ASSEMBLY DIST-AUTHOR
· NANCY JENSEN - APT ASSOCIATION OF SOUTH CENTRAL WI
· MARGARET KIDDER - ST. CLARE MGMT LANDLORD
· TRISTAN PETTIT - ATTORNEY FOR LANDLORDS AND MEMBER OF AASEW
· HEINER GIESE - APT ASSOC OF SE WI
· JOANNA ROUSE - ROUSE MGMT
· CRAIG RADDATZ - FIDUCIARY REAL ESTATE
· JOHN FISCHER - WI APT ASSOC
· RUSS KINZLEIN - WI HOUSING ALLIANCE
· BRUCE BOSBEN
· JOE MURRAY - WRA
· BOB WELCH - APARTMENT ASSOC. OF SC WI
· KENT GABNELSEN
· MITCH COLSTAD
· ARIEL SCHOEINGER - TERONOMY BUILDERS INC
· MIKE PIETREK - LA CROSSE AREA REALTORS AND WRA
· DEBBIE MURSCH
Appearances Against
· VICKY SELKOWE - LEGAL ACTION OF WI
· CURT WITYNSKI - LEAGUE OF MUNICIPALITIES
· DANIELLE MAXWELL-PARKER - VILLAGE OF TURTLE LAKE
· SHERYL GEHRMAN - VILLAGE OF TURTLE LAKE
· TIM KABAT - CITY OF LA CROSSE
· LARRY MACDONALD - CITY OF BAYFIELD
· SHAWN REILLY - CITY OF WAUKESHA
· KEVIN LAHNER - CITY OF WAUKEHSA
· MAYOR - REILLY - CITY OF WAUKEHSA
· LORI LUTHER - CITY OF BELOIT
· MAYOR STEVE CUMMINGS - OSHKOSH
· BEN STEPANEK - OSHKOSH CITY COUNCIL
· BILL WYMAN - COMMUNITY NEIGHBORHOODS OSHKOSH
· CHIEF BRAD LIGGETT - WI FIRE CHIEFS EDU ASSOC. AND CITY OF BELOIT
· GREGG CLEVELAND - CITY OF LA CROSSE
· ANDERS ZANICHKOWSKY
· RICK MCGRATH
· MARTIN KING - WI FIRE PROTECTION COALITION
· JASON TISH - WI TRUST FOR HISTORIC PRESERVATION
· TAMMI JACKSON - WI BOARD FOR PEOPLE WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES
· JONATHAN BECK - UW- ARCHITECTURAL SCHOOL
· JOHN DECKER
· MARY EMERY - WAUKESHA PRESERVATION ALLIANCE
· DAWN MCCARTHY - MILWAUKEE PRESERVATION ALLIANCE
· SAM BREIDENBACH - MADISON TRUST FOR HISTORIC PRESERVATION
· BRENDA WOOD - CITY OF MILWAUKEE
· MIKE GOODMAN
· FRED MOTTS
· AMY KINAST
· B KONKEL
· EDWARD KUHARSKI
Appearances for Information Only
· None.
Registrations For
· JEAN ANTOINE
· JIM SWEENEY
· DAWN SWINGEM - ROUSE MGMT
· FRED ROUSE - ROUSE MGMT
· MATT APTER
· SAMANTHA APTER
· NICOLE ROESSLER
· LOUIS ANTOINE
· RUSSELL BIRRENKOTT
· DEDE BIRWOOD - BIRWOOD PROPERTY
· ERIKA SWEENY
· BRIAN HERVAT - KENOSHA LANDLORD ASSOC.
· SAN SEELEY
· STACY SUMWALT - ELLEFSEN COMPANIES
· MICHAEL DILORETO
· TYLER WRIGHT
· JUANITA BUSCHERT
· JEFF MEYER
· WILLIAM RICHARDSON
· ROBERT SHOBILSKE - AASCW
· FRANK LASEE - 1ST SENATE DIST-AUTHOR
· ROB MARCHANT - DJK INVESTMENTS
· TREVOR SCOTT
· JENNIFER OPPNECHT
· MARGARET WATSON
· ALYSSA HELLENBRAND-BEST
· GARY WEGNER
· SHARON BLOM
· SHERRY COENS
· SARAH HARRINGTON
· TERRI BADGER
· CONNIE CRONON
· ERIC FLOOD - FLOOD HOMES INC
· AMY BLISS - WI HOUSING ALLIANCE
· DALE HICKS - WI APARTMENT ASSOC
· JEFFERY PRALLE - WI APARTMENT ASSOC.
· SCOTT GRABINS
Registrations Against
· DAVID AHREINS - MADISON CITY COUNCIL
· M BACHHUBER - WI INDEPENDENT LIVING NETWORK
· GENIE OGDEN
· MARY ANGLIN
· REP EVAN GOYKE - 18TH ASSEMBLY DIST
· NICK ZAVOS - CITY OF MADISON
· MARY BROWN - NAACP CONFERENCE OF BRANCHES
· JENNELL BALLERING
· BEN ZELLERS
· ANGELA RIERTA
· LINDA HORVATH
· JADYN SKJERVEM
· MAHLON MITCHELL - PROFESSIONAL FIRE FIGHTERS OF WI
· FRANCES INGEBRITSON
· TODD SCHMIDT - VILLAGE OF WANNAKEE
· CHAD GROSSEN
· CRAIG DELLER - MADISON TRUST
· TONY GIBART - END DOMESTIC ABUSE WI
· DOUG MCELMURY - PLEASANT PRAIRIE FIRE AND RESCUE
· ARLAN KAY
· CHIEF KEVIN BIERCE - PEWAUKEE FIRE DEPT.
· ZIA BRUCAYA
· DONNA COLLINGWOOD
· ABBIE KURTZ
· REP CHRIS TAYLOR - 76TH ASSEMBLY DIST
· DAVE BLOOM - WI STATE FIRE CHIEFS
· JASON VALERIUS - APA-WI SW DISTRICT
· BRIAN BENDING - OSHKOSH FIRE DEPT.
· TIMOTHY FRANZ - OSHKOSH FIRE DEPT.
· REP. GORDON HINTZ - 54TH ASSEMBLY DIST.
· STEVE HOWARD - WAUKESHA FIRE DEPT.
Registrations for Information Only
· ERIC ESSER - DSPS
· JEFF WEIGAND - DSPS
· KATE EASTON - WI HISTORICAL SOCIETY
· SHANE SANDERSON - EAU CLAIRE CITY-COUNTY HEALTH DEPT
January 21, 2016 Executive Session Held
Present: (7) Representative Jagler; Representatives Allen, Katsma, Murphy, Murtha, Young and Stuck.
Absent: (0) None.
Excused: (2) Representatives R. Brooks and Genrich.
Moved by Representative Murtha, seconded by Representative Allen that Assembly Substitute Amendment 1 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (6) Representative Jagler; Representatives Allen, Katsma, Murphy, Murtha and Young.
Noes: (1) Representative Stuck.
ASSEMBLY SUBSTITUTE AMENDMENT 1 ADOPTION RECOMMENDED, Ayes 6, Noes 1
Moved by Representative Young, seconded by Representative Stuck that Assembly Amendment 1 to Assembly Substitute Amendment 1 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (2) Representatives Young and Stuck.
Noes: (5) Representative Jagler; Representatives Allen, Katsma, Murphy and Murtha.
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENT 1 TO ASSEMBLY SUBSTITUTE AMENDMENT 1 ADOPTION NOT RECOMMENDED, Ayes 2, Noes 5
Moved by Representative Young, seconded by Representative Stuck that Assembly Amendment 2 to Assembly Substitute Amendment 1 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (2) Representatives Young and Stuck.
Noes: (5) Representative Jagler; Representatives Allen, Katsma, Murphy and Murtha.
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENT 2 TO ASSEMBLY SUBSTITUTE AMENDMENT 1 ADOPTION NOT RECOMMENDED, Ayes 2, Noes 5
Moved by Representative Young, seconded by Representative Stuck that Assembly Amendment 3 to Assembly Substitute Amendment 1 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (2) Representatives Young and Stuck.
Noes: (5) Representative Jagler; Representatives Allen, Katsma, Murphy and Murtha.
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENT 3 TO ASSEMBLY SUBSTITUTE AMENDMENT 1 ADOPTION NOT RECOMMENDED, Ayes 2, Noes 5
Moved by Representative Young, seconded by Representative Stuck that Assembly Amendment 4 to Assembly Substitute Amendment 1 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (2) Representatives Young and Stuck.
Noes: (5) Representative Jagler; Representatives Allen, Katsma, Murphy and Murtha.
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENT 4 TO ASSEMBLY SUBSTITUTE AMENDMENT 1 ADOPTION NOT RECOMMENDED, Ayes 2, Noes 5
Moved by Representative Young, seconded by Representative Stuck that Assembly Amendment 5 to Assembly Substitute Amendment 1 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (2) Representatives Young and Stuck.
Noes: (5) Representative Jagler; Representatives Allen, Katsma, Murphy and Murtha.
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENT 5 TO ASSEMBLY SUBSTITUTE AMENDMENT 1 ADOPTION NOT RECOMMENDED, Ayes 2, Noes 5
Moved by Representative Young, seconded by Representative Stuck that Assembly Amendment 6 to Assembly Substitute Amendment 1 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (2) Representatives Young and Stuck.
Noes: (5) Representative Jagler; Representatives Allen, Katsma, Murphy and Murtha.
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENT 6 TO ASSEMBLY SUBSTITUTE AMENDMENT 1 ADOPTION NOT RECOMMENDED, Ayes 2, Noes 5
Moved by Representative Young, seconded by Representative Stuck that Assembly Amendment 7 to Assembly Substitute Amendment 1 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (2) Representatives Young and Stuck.
Noes: (5) Representative Jagler; Representatives Allen, Katsma, Murphy and Murtha.
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENT 7 TO ASSEMBLY SUBSTITUTE AMENDMENT 1 ADOPTION NOT RECOMMENDED, Ayes 2, Noes 5
Moved by Representative Young, seconded by Representative Stuck that Assembly Amendment 8 to Assembly Substitute Amendment 1 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (2) Representatives Young and Stuck.
Noes: (5) Representative Jagler; Representatives Allen, Katsma, Murphy and Murtha.
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENT 8 TO ASSEMBLY SUBSTITUTE AMENDMENT 1 ADOPTION NOT RECOMMENDED, Ayes 2, Noes 5
Moved by Representative Young, seconded by Representative Stuck that Assembly Amendment 9 to Assembly Substitute Amendment 1 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (2) Representatives Young and Stuck.
Noes: (5) Representative Jagler; Representatives Allen, Katsma, Murphy and Murtha.
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENT 9 TO ASSEMBLY SUBSTITUTE AMENDMENT 1 ADOPTION NOT RECOMMENDED, Ayes 2, Noes 5
Moved by Representative Young, seconded by Representative Stuck that Assembly Amendment 10 to Assembly Substitute Amendment 1 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (2) Representatives Young and Stuck.
Noes: (5) Representative Jagler; Representatives Allen, Katsma, Murphy and Murtha.
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENT 10 TO ASSEMBLY SUBSTITUTE AMENDMENT 1 ADOPTION NOT RECOMMENDED, Ayes 2, Noes 5
Moved by Representative Young, seconded by Representative Stuck that Assembly Amendment 11 to Assembly Substitute Amendment 1 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (2) Representatives Young and Stuck.
Noes: (5) Representative Jagler; Representatives Allen, Katsma, Murphy and Murtha.
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENT 11 TO ASSEMBLY SUBSTITUTE AMENDMENT 1 ADOPTION NOT RECOMMENDED, Ayes 2, Noes 5
Moved by Representative Young, seconded by Representative Stuck that Assembly Amendment 12 to Assembly Substitute Amendment 1 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (2) Representatives Young and Stuck.
Noes: (5) Representative Jagler; Representatives Allen, Katsma, Murphy and Murtha.
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENT 12 TO ASSEMBLY SUBSTITUTE AMENDMENT 1 ADOPTION NOT RECOMMENDED, Ayes 2, Noes 5
Moved by Representative Murtha, seconded by Representative Allen that Assembly Bill 568 be recommended for passage as amended.
Ayes: (5) Representative Jagler; Representatives Allen, Katsma, Murphy and Murtha.
Noes: (2) Representatives Young and Stuck.
PASSAGE AS AMENDED RECOMMENDED, Ayes 5, Noes 2
______________________________
Charlie Bellin
Committee Clerk