Register October 2004 No. 586
Chapter ATCP 109
ATCP 109.01   Definitions.
ATCP 109.02   Prohibited trade practices.
ATCP 109.03   Contract requirements.
ATCP 109.04   Custom cutters.
Ch. ATCP 109 Note Note: Chapter Ag 109 was renumbered chapter ATCP 109 under s. 13.93 (2m) (b) 1., Stats., Register, April, 1993, No. 448.
Ch. ATCP 109 Note Note: This chapter is adopted under authority of s. 100.20 (2), Stats., and is administered by the Wisconsin department of agriculture, trade and consumer protection. Violations of this chapter may be prosecuted under s. 100.20 (6), 100.26 (3) or (6), Stats. A person who suffers a monetary loss because of a violation of this chapter may sue the violator directly under s. 100.20 (5), Stats., and may recover twice the amount of the loss, together with costs and reasonable attorneys' fees.
ATCP 109.01 ATCP 109.01Definitions.
ATCP 109.01(1) (1) “ Buyer" means both actual and prospective purchasers but does not include persons purchasing for resale.
ATCP 109.01(2) (2) “Contract" means all written agreements subscribed by a buyer and includes promissory notes and sales agreements.
ATCP 109.01(3) (3) “Food service plan" means any contract under which the seller agrees to furnish the buyer with any food, or food and any other product or service, whether or not a membership fee or similar charge is involved. It includes a contract to furnish a wholesale cut.
ATCP 109.01(4) (4) “Misrepresent" means the use of any untrue, deceptive or misleading oral or written statement, advertisement, label, display, picture, illustration or sample.
ATCP 109.01(5) (5) “Person" means individuals, corporations, partnerships and any other form of business organization, and all officers, directors, agents, employees and representatives thereof.
ATCP 109.01(6) (6) “Custom cutter" means one who breaks down carcass meat into retail cuts.
ATCP 109.01(7) (7) “Product" means food and non-food consumer goods unless otherwise indicated.
ATCP 109.01(8) (8) “Represent" means the use of any form of oral or written statement, advertising, label, display, picture, illustration or sample.
ATCP 109.01(9) (9) “Seller" means any person soliciting or making a sale, whether or not a contract is involved, and includes a principal or any other person for whom the sale is procured.
ATCP 109.01(10) (10) “Wholesale cut" means a whole carcass of beef, swine or sheep or any part thereof customarily classified as being of commercial size and usually requiring further cutting into cuts of retail size for use by consumers.
ATCP 109.01 History History: Cr. Register, September, 1967, No. 141, eff. 1-1-68; am. (2), Register, December, 1967, No. 144, eff. 1-1-68; am. (2), (3) and (4), renum. (6) to (9) to be (7) to (10) and cr. (6), Register, June, 1975, No. 234, eff. 7-1-75; correction in (9) made under s. 13.93 (2m) (b) 5., Stats., Register, April, 1993, No. 448.
ATCP 109.02 ATCP 109.02Prohibited trade practices. No person advertising, offering for sale or selling any wholesale cut or food service plan shall engage in any unfair methods of competition or unfair trade practices, and particularly including, but not limited to the following:
ATCP 109.02(1) (1)Bait selling.
ATCP 109.02(1)(a)(a) Disparage or degrade any product advertised or offered for sale by the seller, or display any product or depiction thereof to any buyer in such a manner as would be likely to discourage the sale of the advertised or offered product, in order to induce the purchase of another product, or represent that a product is for sale when such representation is used primarily to sell another product.
ATCP 109.02(1)(b) (b) Substitute any product for that ordered by the buyer without the buyer's consent.
ATCP 109.02(1)(c) (c) Fail to have available a sufficient quantity of any product represented as being for sale to meet reasonably anticipated demands, unless the available amount is disclosed fully and conspicuously.
ATCP 109.02(2) (2)Price concessions and special offers.
ATCP 109.02(2)(a)(a) Misrepresent to the buyer that the buyer is being given an introductory, confidential, close-out, going out of business, factory, packer, special or wholesale price or discount, grand opening or any similar price concession. Grand opening sales shall not extend more than 21 days after the first announcement of the promotion.
ATCP 109.02(2)(b) (b) Offer any gift or prize, without fully and conspicuously disclosing all terms of the offer, including all rules, conditions and the expiration date of the offer. Any gift or prize offered shall be given at the time any potential recipient qualifies for the gift or prize as set forth in the offer.
ATCP 109.02(2)(c) (c) Misrepresent that insurance or some other form of protection is available to the buyer, or misrepresent the terms, conditions or limitations thereof.
ATCP 109.02(2)(d) (d) Misrepresent that the buyer will receive certain benefits or privileges from payment of a membership fee or similar charge, or fail to furnish to the buyer prior to the signing of any contract a written statement of all such benefits and privileges.
ATCP 109.02(3) (3)Savings representations.
ATCP 109.02(3)(a)(a) Use any price list related to the seller's food service plan which contains prices other than the seller's current billing prices.
ATCP 109.02(3)(b) (b) Fail to furnish to, and leave with the buyer prior to the signing of any contract or the placing of any order pursuant to the contract, a written copy of a current price list which shall contain an accurate description and the billing price of each product on the list including, whenever applicable, for food products: grade, net weight or measure, brand or trade name; and for non-food products: brand or trade name, model number and year, size or capacity. All price lists shall conspicuously specify an expiration date. Orders placed with the seller prior to the expiration date shall be billed at the prices set forth in such current price list.
ATCP 109.02(3)(c) (c) Misrepresent the amount of money that the buyer will save on purchases of any product or compare the seller's prices either with prices of other sellers not selling in the same trade area or with prices of products which are not of the same grade or quality.
ATCP 109.02(3)(d) (d) Represent to the buyer that a specified amount of food products or the cost thereof is sufficient to meet the requirements of the buyer. Any computation as to amount of food required shall be determined solely by the buyer, except that the seller may furnish current official government data on average food consumption and costs. A written itemization of all food to be sold, with the price and accurate description of each item including, whenever applicable, grade, net weight or measure, and brand or trade name shall be furnished to the buyer prior to the signing of any contract.
ATCP 109.02(3)(e) (e) Misrepresent that the buyer can purchase all or most of the buyer's food requirements, or any non-food product in connection with a food service plan.
ATCP 109.02(4) (4)Guarantees.
ATCP 109.02(4)(a)(a) Represent that the same products and services offered for sale by the seller of a food service plan will be available to the buyer from sellers in other areas without payment of another membership fee or similar charge by the buyer unless the seller agrees to refund such membership fee or similar charge in full if the seller cannot arrange for the buyer to receive such products and services elsewhere.
ATCP 109.02(4)(b) (b) Make any promise, either to exchange unsatisfactory food products or to give a refund therefor, which expires in less than 60 days from the date of delivery of such products, or fail to honor such promise, where through no fault of the buyer, said food does not meet minimum standards of quality expected by the ordinary consumer.
ATCP 109.02(4)(c) (c) Give any guarantee or warranty which is not clear and specific or with which the seller is unable to comply; or misrepresent that someone else is the guarantor or warrantor of any product or service, or fail to furnish the buyer with a copy of such guarantee or warranty.
ATCP 109.02(4)(d) (d) Misrepresent the date of performance of any contract.
ATCP 109.02(5) (5)Identity of seller.
ATCP 109.02(5)(a)(a) Represent that a person is, or that the seller will provide the service of, a nutritionist or home economist, unless such person has completed specialized training in such fields or is otherwise technically qualified.
ATCP 109.02(5)(b) (b) Misrepresent that the seller, products or service have been approved by any better business bureau, chamber of commerce, service club, financial institution, government agency or any other commercial or civic organization, or any official or employee thereof, or that the seller is a member of such organization.
ATCP 109.02(6) (6)Price and financing.
ATCP 109.02(6)(a)(a) Misrepresent or fail to disclose fully and conspicuously at the time of the sale, the name of the financing institution or contract assignee, if any.
ATCP 109.02(6)(b) (b) Fail to advise the buyer before signing any contract that the contract may be transferred or assigned to a financial institution or other third party and payment enforced by them.
ATCP 109.02(6)(c) (c) Misrepresent the total amount that the buyer will be obligated to pay.
ATCP 109.02(6)(d) (d) Misrepresent that the offer or sale or any part thereof is made on a trial basis, or fail to disclose fully and conspicuously that the buyer must pay a membership fee or similar charge in full if such payment is required.
ATCP 109.02(6)(e) (e) Misrepresent that the seller will pay or reimburse the buyer for the expenses of delivering or moving a freezer or any other product for the buyer.
ATCP 109.02(6)(f) (f) Fail to disclose fully and conspicuously any extra charges for cutting, wrapping, freezing, delivery or other services.
ATCP 109.02(6)(g) (g) Represent the price of a wholesale cut in terms other than price per single pound.
ATCP 109.02(6)(h) (h) In all wholesale cut advertising which in any manner represents the availability of credit terms or payment plans, the seller shall fully disclose if the purchaser must obligate himself or herself to a party other than the seller if the total of the purchaser's obligation is not fully paid at the time of delivery.
ATCP 109.02(7) (7)Product representation.
ATCP 109.02(7)(a)(a) Misrepresent the cut, grade, brand or trade name, or weight or measure of any food product.
ATCP 109.02(7)(b) (b) Use the abbreviation “ U.S." in describing a food product not graded by the United States department of agriculture, except that foods may be described as “U.S. Inspected" when true.
ATCP 109.02(7)(c) (c) Misrepresent a food product through the use of any term similar to a government grade.
ATCP 109.02(7)(d) (d) Fail to disclose, when a yield grade is advertised, a definition of the yield grade in the following terms:
“Yield Grade 1—Extra Lean"
“Yield Grade 2—Lean"
“Yield Grade 3—Average Waste"
“Yield Grade 4—Wasty"
“Yield Grade 5—Exceptionally Wasty"
ATCP 109.02(7)(e) (e) Advertise or offer for sale in combinations wholesale cuts with one unit price.
ATCP 109.02(7)(f) (f) Fail to disclose fully and conspicuously the correct government grade for any food product if such product is represented as having been graded.
ATCP 109.02(7)(g) (g) Fail to disclose fully and conspicuously that the yield of consumable meat from any wholesale cut will be less than the weight of the wholesale cut. The seller shall, for each wholesale cut advertised, use separately and distinctly in at least 10 point type the following disclosure: “Sold hanging weight subject to cutting loss."
ATCP 109.02(7)(h) (h) Misrepresent the amount or proportion of retail cuts that a wholesale cut of meat will yield.
ATCP 109.02(7)(i) (i) Fail to furnish the buyer with a complete and accurate signed statement, at the time of delivery, showing the net weight of meat delivered to the buyer. If weighed with immediate wrappings, such fact shall be stated. Both the actual net weight of the wholesale cut, prior to cutting and trimming, and the delivered weight shall be disclosed to the buyer in writing at time of delivery. This section shall apply separately to each wholesale cut sold on any individual order.
ATCP 109.02(7)(j) (j) Fail to disclose fully and conspicuously whether a quarter of a carcass is the front or hind quarter, or represent any meat as a quarter if it has been cut from a quarter prior to sale.
ATCP 109.02(7)(k) (k) Represent any wholesale cut as a “half" or “side" unless it consists of a front and hind quarter. Both quarters shall be from the same side of the same animal unless the seller discloses fully and conspicuously that they are from different sides or different animals as the case may be. Each quarter shall be of the same grade or quality as the other quarters comprising the half or side and the seller shall advise the buyer of the weight of each quarter prior to sale. In selling quarters individually or as part of a half or side, if actual weights are not known or cannot be determined prior to sale, approximate weights may be used, provided: The buyer is informed that the weights are approximate, the weights are so identified on any purchase order or contract, and the seller agrees with the buyer, in writing, to make a cash refund or grant a credit on delivery for the difference between actual weight and the approximate weight on which the sale was made.
ATCP 109.02(7)(L) (L) Use the words “bundle", “sample order", “split side", or words of similar import to describe a quantity of meat or poultry unless the seller itemizes each cut and the weight thereof which the buyer will receive.
ATCP 109.02(7)(m) (m) Advertise or offer free, bonus or extra product or service combined with or conditioned on the purchase of any other product or service unless such additional product or service is accurately described including, whenever applicable, grade, net weight or measure, type, and brand or trade name. The words “free," “bonus," or other words of similar import, shall not be used in any advertisement unless the advertisement clearly and conspicuously sets forth the total price or amount which must be paid to entitle the buyer to the additional product or service.
ATCP 109.02(7)(n) (n) Misrepresent the breed, origin or diet of slaughtered animals or parts thereof offered for sale. Sellers making such claims shall have written records available to substantiate such fact.
ATCP 109.02(7)(o) (o) Represent the price of any food freezer without fully and conspicuously disclosing its brand or trade name, model number and year, and size or capacity.
ATCP 109.02 History History: Cr. Register, September, 1967, No. 141, eff. 1-1-68; am. (4) (b) and (7) (g) and (i), Register, December, 1967, No. 144, eff. 1-1-68; am. (6) (b), Register, May, 1968, No. 149, eff. 6-1-68; am. (1) (intro. par.), (1) (a), (3) (a), (4) (b), (6) (a), (6) (b), and (6) (g), r. (2) (a), renum. (2) (b) and (c) to be (2) (a) and (b) and am., renum. (2) (d) and (e) to be (2) (c) and (d), renum. (3) (b) to (d) to be (3) (c) to (e), am. (3) (d), cr. (3) (b), cr. (6) (h), renum. (7) (d) to (m) to be (7) (f) to (o), am. (7) (g), (i), (l) and (m) and cr. (7) (d) and (e), Register, June, 1975, No. 234, eff. 7-1-75; corrections made under s. 13.93 (2m) (b) 5., Stats., Register, April, 1993, No. 448.
ATCP 109.03 ATCP 109.03Contract requirements.
ATCP 109.03(1) (1)Service plan. Any seller of a food service plan which does not involve an extension of credit shall comply with the following:
ATCP 109.03(1)(a) (a) Give the buyer at the time of execution a true copy of the contract, which shall include its date of execution and all terms and conditions of the sale and a copy of any price list, guarantee, service agreement or other document incorporated or referred to in the contract.
ATCP 109.03(1)(b) (b) Print clearly and conspicuously on the contract the name and mailing address of the seller.
ATCP 109.03(1)(c) (c) All blank spaces shall be filled in or a line drawn through them before the contract is signed by the buyer.
Published under s. 35.93, Stats. Updated on the first day of each month. Entire code is always current. The Register date on each page is the date the chapter was last published.