MULLANE, MICHAEL PATRICK, of Milwaukee, as a Medicine and Surgery Representative on the Genetic Counselors Affiliated Credentialing Board, to serve for the term ending July 1, 2024.
Ayes: 5 - Senators Jacque, Bradley, Carpenter, Wirch and Knodl.
Noes: 0 - None.
MURIELLO, MICHAEL J., of Brookfield, as a Medicine and Surgery Representative on the Genetic Counselors Affiliated Credentialing Board, to serve for the term ending July 1, 2023.
Ayes: 5 - Senators Jacque, Bradley, Carpenter, Wirch and Knodl.
Noes: 0 - None.
MURIELLO, DR. MICHAEL, of Brookfield, as a Medicine and Surgery Representative on the Genetic Counselors Affiliated Credentialing Board, to serve for the term ending July 1, 2027.
Ayes: 5 - Senators Jacque, Bradley, Carpenter, Wirch and Knodl.
Noes: 0 - None.
NOVAK, LAURA, of Madison, as a Massage/Bodywork Therapist Representative on the Massage Therapy and Bodywork Therapy Affiliated Credentialing Board, to serve for the term ending July 1, 2027.
Ayes: 5 - Senators Jacque, Bradley, Carpenter, Wirch and Knodl.
Noes: 0 - None.
PABST, REBECCA L., of La Crosse, as a Genetic Counselor on the Genetic Counselors Affiliated Credentialing Board, to serve for the term ending July 1, 2025.
Ayes: 5 - Senators Jacque, Bradley, Carpenter, Wirch and Knodl.
Noes: 0 - None.
PALARSKI, VALERIE A., of Aniwa, as a Public Member on the Board on Aging and Long Term Care, to serve for the term ending May 1, 2026.
Ayes: 5 - Senators Jacque, Bradley, Carpenter, Wirch and Knodl.
Noes: 0 - None.
PAZAK, KATHLEEN, of Deerfield, as a Speech/Language Pathologist Representative on the Hearing and Speech Examining Board, to serve for the term ending July 1, 2027.
Ayes: 5 - Senators Jacque, Bradley, Carpenter, Wirch and Knodl.
Noes: 0 - None.
PORTER, EDWARD, of Elm Grove, as a Professional Member on the Cemetery Board, to serve for the term ending July 1, 2027.
Ayes: 5 - Senators Jacque, Bradley, Carpenter, Wirch and Knodl.
Noes: 0 - None.
TRUDEAU, RAMONA, of Waldo, as a Massage or Bodywork Therapy School Representative on the Massage Therapy and Bodywork Therapy Affiliated Credentialing Board, to serve for the term ending July 1, 2027.
Ayes: 5 - Senators Jacque, Bradley, Carpenter, Wirch and Knodl.
Noes: 0 - None.
The committee on Licensing, Constitution and Federalism reported:
LYNCH-DECOMBHS, DIANE, of Fort Atkinson, as a Nursing Home Administrator Representative on the Nursing Home Administrator Examining Board, to serve for the term ending July 1, 2024.
Ayes: 2 - Senators Carpenter and Wirch.
Noes: 3 - Senators Jacque, Bradley and Knodl.
ANDRÉ JACQUE
Chairperson
_____________
Petitions and Communications
hist173213Pursuant to Senate Rule 17 (5), Representative Joers added as a cosponsor of Senate Bill 23. hist173357Pursuant to Senate Rule 17 (5), Representative O'Connor added as a cosponsor of Senate Bill 121. hist173362Pursuant to Senate Rule 17 (5), Representative C. Anderson added as a cosponsor of Senate Bill 400. hist173317Pursuant to Senate Rule 17 (5), Representative Rettinger added as a cosponsor of Senate Bill 427. hist173363Pursuant to Senate Rule 17 (5), Representative Billings added as a cosponsor of Senate Bill 430. _____________
State of Wisconsin
Claims Board
September 28, 2023
Attached is the report of the State Claims Board covering the claims considered at the September 7, 2023, meeting of the Board.
This report is for the information of the Legislature, The Board would appreciate your acceptance and publication of it in the Journal to inform the members of the Legislature.
Sincerely,
ANNE HANSON
Secretary
STATE OF WISCONSIN CLAIMS BOARD
On September 7, 2023, the State of Wisconsin Claims Board met in the State Capitol Building and via Zoom videoconference to consider the following claims:
Hearings were conducted for the following claims:
Claimant Agency Amount
11.
Budget Dumpster LLC Revenue $88,518.58 22.
Sandra Beulen Corrections $2,414.14 The following claims were decided without hearings:
Claimant Agency Amount
33.
Brendan Ingenthorn Corrections $274.99 44.
Martha Vazquez Transportation $17,064.89 55.
Jacquese Harrell, Sr. Corrections $1,750.43 66.
Eugene Cherry Corrections $162.39 77.
Patrick Fowler Corrections $242.02 88.
De’Angelo Carter Corrections $467.60 99.
Jennifer Arndt Natural Resources $567.59 With respect to the claims, the Board finds:
(Decisions are unanimous unless otherwise noted.)
1. Budget Dumpster, LLC of Westlake, OH claims $88,518.58 for refund of sales/use taxes levied by DOR. Claimant contracts with third parties to provide waste removal services for customers in Wisconsin. Claimant alleges that it registered for a Wisconsin seller’s permit in 2011, but later determined a permit was not necessary because taxable services were not being provided. Claimant did not cancel the permit and did not file sales/use tax returns in Wisconsin. DOR eventually sent estimated assessments in 2018, 2019, and 2020. In June 2021, DOR began levying funds to cover the assessments. Claimant started working with MCE Salt Solutions LLP (a sales and use tax consulting firm) in March 2022. MCE confirmed with DOR that Claimant’s services were not taxable. Claimant indicates that the permit was cancelled at that time, and in-process assessments were closed. Claimant sought to recover the funds that had been levied but was advised by DOR those refunds would not be released until income/franchise returns were filed. Claimant filed and paid the tax returns in July and August 2022, totaling $23,293.00. At that time, Claimant was not aware that the funds would not be fully refunded. Claimant received refunds in 2022 for the periods of 12/31/19 to 12/31/21, totaling approximately $12,000, but was notified by DOR that per Wis. Stat. § 77.59(4)(b), the statute of limitations (SOL) had closed for the tax periods ending 3/31/2011 to 9/30/2019. Claimant disagrees and believes the SOL for applying for a refund does not close until June 2023, because the funds were levied (i.e., paid) in June 2021. Claimant holds it had no reason to apply for a refund by September 2020 (the SOL calculated by DOR), because levies did not begin until June 2021. Claimant further believes that the remaining levied AMEX funds should be refunded based on “compromise” authority available to DOR. DOR recommends this claim be denied. DOR has no record of Claimant applying for or receiving a seller’s permit. DOR contends it issued estimated assessments based on survey responses received by Claimant, which led DOR to believe that taxable services were being provided. DOR alleges it sent Claimant approximately 58 letters between June 2018 and March 2022 to obtain additional information but was not contacted by Claimant (through MCE) until March 2022. (Of note, Claimant alleges not to have received any of the 58 letters sent by DOR, and that it may be attributed to mailing issues and/or staff working remotely during that time period.) DOR holds that the two-year SOL runs from the date of assessment, rather than the payment (levy) date. The remaining estimated assessments were issued in 2018 and 2019. Claimant had two years from issuance to apply for a refund. Therefore, Claimant had until September 2020 to apply for a refund on most of the assessments. Lastly, DOR notes that the Tax Appeals Commission has held that the phrase “and paid” is included in the statute (Wis. Stat. § 77.59(4)(b)) to clarify that an assessment must be paid before a refund claim can be filed. DOR holds it has done all in its power and does not have the authority to use fair and equitable relief powers to circumvent the SOL.
The Board defers its decision on this claim at this time in order to obtain additional information from the parties.
2. Sandra Beulen of Oakfield, WI claims $2,414.14 for vehicle damage incurred due to an accident with a snowplow at Oshkosh Correctional Institution on December 15, 2022. Beulen arrived for work around 7:15 AM while the parking lot was being plowed and pulled into a cleared parking space. Beulen wanted to straighten her vehicle in the stall, so she checked behind her and saw the snowplow two aisles away. She slowly backed up about three feet and when she stopped and put her car into drive to pull forward, the snowplow turned into her aisle and struck her vehicle. In support of her claim, Beulen provides an affidavit from another DOC employee, who states that he saw the plow truck pull wide around the corner and strike Beulen’s stopped vehicle. The plow driver called in the accident but then ignored instructions to wait at the scene until someone arrived to take photos. Beulen swiftly submitted repair estimates as instructed and repeatedly tried to reach Sentry Insurance, the State’s insurance adjuster, but they were not responsive. Sentry eventually took Beulen’s statement on January 30, 2023, at which time she informed them that her vehicle repair was scheduled for March 6. Sentry told her that the repair cost would be paid and that she would be contacted by an adjuster, which never happened. DOC staff attempted to reach Sentry on Beulen’s behalf but were unsuccessful. Towards the end of February, Beulen was informed that the plow driver was refusing to return Sentry’s phone calls but that his supervisor was going to intervene to ensure he cooperated with the investigation. Beulen’s vehicle was repaired as scheduled on March 6, 2023. Two days later, Sentry notified Beulen that she was 45% responsible for the accident because both vehicles had been moving at the time of the collision. Sentry offered to pay $560.62 for the repairs, which was half of the “estimate of record” by Sentry’s appraisers. Beulen denies that her vehicle was moving at the time of the accident. She believes the plow driver provided a false account of the accident because, having been restricted from driving state vehicles in the past, he might face discipline for another infraction.
DOC believes Beulen has failed to show negligence on the part of the state and recommends denial of this claim. The account of the accident given by both drivers is consistent in most respects. The snowplow driver stated that he tried to stop when he saw Beulen’s vehicle back out of the stall, but he was unable to avoid hitting her. DOC notes that the snowplow driver could not have been two lanes over when Beulen backed out of the stall as she alleges. DOC believes Beulen was negligent in failing to look before backing up. The investigation of the accident found that the snowplow driver was not impaired, driving too fast, or distracted, he was simply unable to react quickly enough to avoid an accident when Beulen backed out in front of him.
_Hlk145416100 The Board concludes the claim should be paid in the amount of $2,414.14 based on equitable principles. The Board further concludes, under authority of Wis. Stat. § 16.007(6m), payment should be made from the Department of Corrections appropriation Wis. Stat. § 20.410 (1)(a). 3. Brendan Ingenthron of Tomah, WI claims $274.99 for the unreimbursed value of damaged personal property. Ingenthron is an employee at New Lisbon Correctional Institution. On May 30, 2023, an inmate threw a full coffee mug mixture of feces and urine at Ingenthron, which ruined his clothes and caused his glucose monitor to stop working. Ingenthron submitted a Nonrepresented Employee Claim for Reimbursement for Damaged Personal Articles to DOC; however, the department was limited by the State of Wisconsin Compensation plan, which caps reimbursement for personal articles at $100. Ingenthron requests reimbursement for the remaining value of his clothing and glucose monitor.
DOC supports payment of this claim based on equitable principles. The damage to Ingenthron’s personal clothing and glucose monitor was not due to his or another employee’s carelessness. Nor was the damage a result of normal wear and tear while acting within the scope of employment.
The Board concludes the claim should be paid in the amount of $274.99 based on equitable principles. The Board further concludes, under authority of Wis. Stat. § 16.007(6m), payment should be made from the Department of Corrections appropriation Wis. Stat. § 20.410 (1)(a).
