980.08 Annotation
Under sub. (6m) [formerly s. 980.06 (2) (d)], a circuit court must determine whether any rule or condition of release has been violated or whether the safety of others requires revocation. A circuit court is not required to expressly consider alternatives to revocation before revoking a sexually violent person's supervised release when the court determines that the safety of the public requires the person's commitment to a secure facility. State v. Burris, 2004 WI 91,
273 Wis. 2d 294,
682 N.W.2d 812,
00-1425.
980.08 Annotation
The sufficiency of evidence standard of review applies when reviewing a circuit court's order denying a petition for supervised release under sub. (4). The test for the sufficiency of the evidence to support the order is not whether a reviewing court is convinced by clear and convincing evidence that a person's petition for supervised release should be denied, but whether a circuit court, acting reasonably, could be so convinced by evidence it has a right to believe and accept as true. State v. Brown, 2005 WI 29,
279 Wis. 2d 102,
693 N.W.2d 715,
03-1419.
980.08 Annotation
Supervised Release Under Chapter 980: Alternatives to Protect Wisconsin While Upholding the Constitution. Hamrin. 2007 WLR 889.
980.09
980.09
Petition for discharge. A committed person may petition the committing court for discharge at any time. The court shall deny the petition under this section without a hearing unless the petition alleges facts from which the court or jury may conclude the person's condition has changed since the date of his or her initial commitment order so that the person does not meet the criteria for commitment as a sexually violent person.
980.09(2)
(2) The court shall review the petition within 30 days and may hold a hearing to determine if it contains facts from which the court or jury may conclude that the person does not meet the criteria for commitment as a sexually violent person. In determining under this subsection whether facts exist that might warrant such a conclusion, the court shall consider any current or past reports filed under
s. 980.07, relevant facts in the petition and in the state's written response, arguments of counsel, and any supporting documentation provided by the person or the state. If the court determines that the petition does not contain facts from which a court or jury may conclude that the person does not meet the criteria for commitment, the court shall deny the petition. If the court determines that facts exist from which a court or jury could conclude the person does not meet criteria for commitment the court shall set the matter for hearing.
980.09(3)
(3) The court shall hold a hearing within 90 days of the determination that the petition contains facts from which the court or jury may conclude that the person does not meet the criteria for commitment as a sexually violent person. The state has the burden of proving by clear and convincing evidence that the person meets the criteria for commitment as a sexually violent person.
980.09(4)
(4) If the court or jury is satisfied that the state has not met its burden of proof under
sub. (3), the petitioner shall be discharged from the custody of the department. If the court or jury is satisfied that the state has met its burden of proof under
sub. (3), the court may proceed under
s. 980.08 (4) to determine whether to modify the petitioner's existing commitment order by authorizing supervised release.
980.09 Annotation
Persons committed under ch. 980 must be afforded the right to request a jury for discharge hearings under this section. State v. Post,
197 Wis. 2d 279,
541 N.W.2d 115 (1995),
94-2356.
980.09 Annotation
Sub. (2) (a) does not contemplate an evidentiary hearing as is provided under sub. (2) (b). Under sub. (2) (a), the hearing is a paper review of the reexamination reports that allows the committing court to weed out frivolous petitions. State v. Paulick,
213 Wis. 2d 432,
570 N.W.2d 626 (Ct. App. 1997),
96-3410.
980.09 Annotation
The right to counsel under sub. (2) (a) is subject to the same standards and procedures for resolving right to counsel issues as in criminal cases. State v. Thiel, 2001 WI App 32,
241 Wis. 2d 465,
626 N.W.2d 26,
00-0142.
980.09 Annotation
Sub. (2) (a) does not allow unlimited submission of evidence, but does allow the submission of a second medical examination report. State v. Thayer, 2001 WI App 51,
241 Wis. 2d 417,
626 N.W.2d 811,
98-3691.
980.09 Annotation
Probable cause that a detainee is no longer a sexually violent person is not demonstrated by an expert's conclusion that the detainee has the ability to control his or her behavior. A court must not only consider whether the person has the ability to make choices, but the degree to which those choices are driven by a mental disorder. Pedophilia is a mental disorder that by definition includes a diagnosis of lack of control. State v. Schiller, 2003 WI App 195,
266 Wis. 2d 992,
669 N.W.2d 747,
02-2963.
980.09 Annotation
Progress in treatment is one way of showing that a person is not still a sexually violent person under sub. (2) (a). A new diagnosis is another. A new diagnosis need not attack the original finding that an individual was sexually violent, but focuses on the present and is evidence of whether an individual is still a sexually violent person. State v. Pocan, 2003 WI App 233,
267 Wis. 2d 953,
671 N.W.2d 680,
02-3342.
980.09 Annotation
The question at a sub. (2) (a) probable cause hearing is whether probable cause exists to establish that the individual seeking discharge is no longer a sexually violent person and is not whether the individual is substantially probable to engage in acts of sexual violence if placed on supervised release or even if discharged from commitment. Probable cause to believe a person is no longer a sexually violent person is not satisfied by a recommendation of supervised release without more. State v. Thiel, 2004 WI App 140,
275 Wis. 2d 421,
685 N.W.2d 890,
03-2098.
980.09 Annotation
In order to provide a basis for probable cause to believe a person is no longer sexually violent under sub. (2), an expert's opinion must depend upon something more than facts, professional knowledge, or research that was considered by an expert testifying in a prior proceeding that determined the person to be sexually violent. State v. Combs, 2006 WI App 137,
295 Wis. 2d 457,
720 N.W.2d 684,
05-0859.
980.09 Annotation
The probable cause determination under sub. (2) (a) is the same as the probable cause determination in a preliminary examination in a criminal proceeding. In assessing one or more re-examination reports at a hearing under sub. (2)(a), the circuit court is to determine whether there is a plausible expert opinion that, if believed, would establish probable cause to believe a person is no longer a sexually violent person within the meaning of the statute under the standard established in Combs. If there are two reports with conflicting opinions on this point, the court does not decide which it finds the more persuasive. State v. Kruse, 2006 WI App 179,
296 Wis. 2d 130,
722 N.W. 2d 742,
04-3081.
980.095
980.095
Procedures for discharge hearings. 980.095(1)(a)(a) The district attorney or the department of justice, whichever filed the original petition, or the petitioner or his or her attorney may request that a hearing under
s. 980.09 (3) be to a jury of 6. A jury trial is deemed waived unless it is demanded within 10 days of the filing of the petition for discharge.
980.095(1)(b)
(b) Juries shall be selected and treated in the same manner as they are selected and treated in civil actions in circuit court. The number of jurors prescribed in
par. (a), plus the number of peremptory challenges available to all of the parties, shall be called initially and maintained in the jury box by calling others to replace jurors excused for cause until all jurors have been examined. The parties shall exercise in their order, the state beginning, the peremptory challenges available to them, and if any party declines to challenge, the challenge shall be made by the clerk by lot.
980.095(1)(c)
(c) No verdict shall be valid or received unless at least 5 of the jurors agree to it.
980.095(2)
(2) Post verdict motions. Motions after verdict may be made without further notice upon receipt of the verdict.
980.095(3)
(3) Appeals. Any party may appeal an order under this subsection as a final order under
chs. 808 and
809.
980.095 History
History: 2005 a. 434.
980.101
980.101
Reversal, vacation or setting aside of judgment relating to a sexually violent offense; effect. 980.101(1)
(1) In this section, "judgment relating to a sexually violent offense" means a judgment of conviction for a sexually violent offense, an adjudication of delinquency on the basis of a sexually violent offense, or a judgment of not guilty of a sexually violent offense by reason of mental disease or defect.
980.101(2)
(2) If, at any time after a person is committed under
s. 980.06, a judgment relating to a sexually violent offense committed by the person is reversed, set aside, or vacated and that sexually violent offense was a basis for the allegation made in the petition under
s. 980.02 (2) (a), the person may bring a motion for postcommitment relief in the court that committed the person. The court shall proceed as follows on the motion for postcommitment relief:
980.101(2)(a)
(a) If the sexually violent offense was the sole basis for the allegation under
s. 980.02 (2) (a) and there are no other judgments relating to a sexually violent offense committed by the person, the court shall reverse, set aside, or vacate the judgment under
s. 980.05 (5) that the person is a sexually violent person, vacate the commitment order, and discharge the person from the custody of the department.
980.101(2)(b)
(b) If the sexually violent offense was the sole basis for the allegation under
s. 980.02 (2) (a) but there are other judgments relating to a sexually violent offense committed by the person that have not been reversed, set aside, or vacated, or if the sexually violent offense was not the sole basis for the allegation under
s. 980.02 (2) (a), the court shall determine whether to grant the person a new trial under
s. 980.05 because the reversal, setting aside, or vacating of the judgment for the sexually violent offense would probably change the result of the trial.
980.101(3)
(3) An appeal may be taken from an order entered under
sub. (2) as from a final judgment.
980.101 History
History: 2001 a. 16;
2005 a. 253,
434.
980.105
980.105
Determination of county and city, village, or town of residence.
980.105(1m)
(1m) The department shall determine a person's county of residence for the purposes of this chapter by doing all of the following:
980.105(1m)(a)
(a) The department shall consider residence as the voluntary concurrence of physical presence with intent to remain in a place of fixed habitation and shall consider physical presence as prima facie evidence of intent to remain.
980.105(1m)(b)
(b) The department shall apply the criteria for consideration of residence and physical presence under
par. (a) to the facts that existed on the date that the person committed the sexually violent offense that resulted in the sentence, placement, or commitment that was in effect when the petition was filed under
s. 980.02.
980.105(2m)
(2m) The department shall determine a person's city, village, or town of residence for the purposes of
s. 980.08 (5) by doing all of the following:
980.105(2m)(a)
(a) The department shall consider residence as the voluntary concurrence of physical presence with intent to remain in a place of fixed habitation and shall consider physical presence as prima facie evidence of intent to remain.
980.105(2m)(b)
(b) The department shall apply the criteria for consideration of residence and physical presence under
par. (a) to the facts that existed on the date that the person committed the sexually violent offense that resulted in the sentence, placement, or commitment that was in effect when the petition was filed under
s. 980.02.
980.105 Annotation
A person's county of residence shall be determined based on the facts that existed on the date of the underlying offense. A court does not have jurisdiction merely because the defendant was in a Wisconsin prison at the time the petition was filed. State v. Burgess, 2002 WI App 264,
258 Wis. 2d 548,
654 N.W.2d 81,
00-3074. Affirmed on other grounds. 2003 WI 71, 262 WI 2d 354,
665 N.W.2d 124,
00-3074.
980.105 Annotation
The circuit court had jurisdiction to conduct ch. 980 proceedings involving an enrolled tribal member who committed the underlying sexual offense on an Indian reservation. State v. Burgess, 2003 WI 71,
262 Wis. 2d 354,
665 N.W.2d 124,
00-3074.
980.11
980.11
Notice concerning supervised release or discharge. 980.11(1)(a)
(a) "Act of sexual violence" means an act or attempted act that is a basis for an allegation made in a petition under
s. 980.02 (2) (a).
980.11(1)(b)
(b) "Member of the family" means spouse, child, sibling, parent or legal guardian.
980.11(1)(c)
(c) "Victim" means a person against whom an act of sexual violence has been committed.
980.11(2)
(2) If the court places a person on supervised release under
s. 980.08 (4) or discharges a person under
s. 980.09 (4), the department shall do all of the following:
980.11(2)(am)
(am) Make a reasonable attempt to notify whichever of the following persons is appropriate, if he or she can be found, in accordance with
sub. (3):
980.11(2)(am)2.
2. An adult member of the victim's family, if the victim died as a result of the act of sexual violence.
980.11(2)(am)3.
3. The victim's parent or legal guardian, if the victim is younger than 18 years old.
980.11(3)
(3) The notice under
sub. (2) shall inform the department of corrections and the person under
sub. (2) (am) of the name of the person committed under this chapter and the date the person is placed on supervised release or discharged. The department shall send the notice, postmarked at least 7 days before the date the person committed under this chapter is placed on supervised release or discharged, to the department of corrections and to the last-known address of the person under
sub. (2) (am).
980.11(4)
(4) The department shall design and prepare cards for persons specified in
sub. (2) (am) to send to the department. The cards shall have space for these persons to provide their names and addresses, the name of the person committed under this chapter and any other information the department determines is necessary. The department shall provide the cards, without charge, to the department of justice and district attorneys. The department of justice and district attorneys shall provide the cards, without charge, to persons specified in
sub. (2) (am). These persons may send completed cards to the department of health services. All records or portions of records of the department of health services that relate to mailing addresses of these persons are not subject to inspection or copying under
s. 19.35 (1), except as needed to comply with a request by the department of corrections under
s. 301.46 (3) (d).
980.12
980.12
Department duties; costs. 980.12(1)
(1) Except as provided in
ss. 980.031 (3) and
980.07 (1), the department shall pay from the appropriations under
s. 20.435 (2) (a) and
(bm) for all costs relating to the evaluation, treatment, and care of persons evaluated or committed under this chapter.
980.12(2)
(2) By February 1, 2002, the department shall submit a report to the legislature under
s. 13.172 (2) concerning the extent to which pharmacological treatment using an antiandrogen or the chemical equivalent of an antiandrogen has been required as a condition of supervised release under
s. 980.06, 1997 stats., or
s. 980.08 and the effectiveness of the treatment in the cases in which its use has been required.
980.13
980.13
Applicability. This chapter applies to a sexually violent person regardless of whether the person engaged in acts of sexual violence before, on or after June 2, 1994.
980.13 History
History: 1993 a. 479.
980.14(1)(1) In this section, "agency" means the department of corrections, the department of health services, the department of justice, or a district attorney.
980.14(2)
(2) Any agency or officer, employee, or agent of an agency is immune from criminal or civil liability for any acts or omissions as the result of a good faith effort to comply with any provision of this chapter.
