(Citation omitted).
It is not possible to analyze every duty related to property tax administration that might conceivably be transferred by the county board. See 67 Op. Att’y Gen. at 4. Harbick and the opinions of the Attorney General previously discussed do provide a framework for determining the extent to which the statutory functions of the county clerk concerning property tax administration generally under Wis. Stat. ch. 70 and specifically under Wis. Stat. § 70.63 may be transferred to the county auditor or to a person in the department of administration who performs audit functions. There are three limitations upon the county board’s authority to transfer the duties of the county clerk. First, the county board’s ability to transfer duties by using the statutory authority granted under Wis. Stat. §§ 59.47(2) and 59.52(1)(b) is generally limited to the duties of the county clerk as auditor. See 63 Op. Att’y Gen. at 199. Those statutes do not permit the transfer of statutory duties expressly assigned to the county clerk by statute. See Harbick, 138 Wis. 2d at 179. Second, the county board’s ability to transfer duties by using its statutory administrative home rule authority under Wis. Stat. §§ 59.03, 59.04, and 59.51(1) generally does not extend to duties expressly assigned by statute to the clerk and other county elective officials because such statutes normally involve matters of statewide concern that uniformly affect every county. See 77 Op. Att’y Gen. at 115-16. Third, the county board is constitutionally prohibited from transferring “[i]mmemorial duties performed by a constitutional officer . . .” including any immemorial duties of the county clerk that relate to property taxation. Harbick, 138 Wis. 2d at 179. Immemorial duties are important duties that characterized and distinguished the office of clerk at common law when the constitution was adopted. Compare Kocken v. Wisconsin Council 40, 2007 WI 72, ¶¶ 43-44, 301 Wis. 2d 266, 732 N.W.2d 828; State ex rel. Kennedy v. Brunst, 26 Wis. 412, 415 (1870). A general idea of the functions performed by the clerk at approximately the time when the constitution was adopted can be gleaned from the Revised Statutes of 1858. See 24 Op. Att’y Gen. at 793. The functions performed by the clerk at that time do encompass a number of items related to property tax administration, including functions related to the apportionment and equalization of property taxes about which you specifically inquire. See Rev. Stat. ch. 18, sec. 56 (1858): The clerk of the board of supervisors shall, immediately after such apportionments [of property taxes by the county board] make out two certificates of the several amounts apportioned to be assessed upon the taxable property of each town and ward, for state, county, and school purposes, one of which he shall deliver, or cause to be delivered, to the county treasurer and the other to the clerk of the proper town, or city, as the case may be; and the county treasurer shall charge the amount of state and county taxes specified in each certificate, to the proper town or city.
When the constitution was adopted, the clerk did have at least ministerial computation and notification duties. The transfer of such duties by the county board is therefore constitutionally prohibited.
To the extent the Polk County Board may be considering the transfer of immemorial duties of the county clerk or duties expressly assigned by statute by the Legislature to the county clerk, your fact situation is unlike that presented in Harbick. Harbick permitted the duties of keeping accounts to be transferred to a county auditor where such duties clearly did not involve matters of statewide concern that uniformly affect every county because they were not expresslyassigned by the Legislature to the elective office of county clerk and where such duties also were not immemorial duties of the county clerk. Despite the above-described limitations upon the county board’s authority, however, even with respect to property tax administration the county board’s statutory authority under Wis. Stat. §§ 59.03, 59.04, and 59.51(1) in combination with Wis. Stat. §§ 59.47(2) and 59.52(1)(b) does permit the board to “transfer duties of keeping . . . accounts and books of account from the county clerk to some other officer where an express statute d[oes] not require the county clerk to perform the duties” and to “authorize the . . . exercise . . . [of] indirect supervision” by the county auditor or by another appropriate county official in lieu of the county auditor where an express statute does require the county clerk to perform the function. See 65 Op. Att’y Gen. at 136-37. Consequently, although the statutory duties assigned by the Legislature to the county clerk under Wis. Stat. ch. 70 may not be transferred to the county auditor or another appropriate county official in lieu of the county auditor, supervisory authority over the manner in which such duties are exercised may be granted to the county auditor or another appropriate county official in lieu of the county auditor. CONCLUSION
I therefore conclude that (a) although the county board chair appoints the county auditor under civil service procedures, the county board could instead establish a department of administration and assign audit functions to that department in which case the appointment and removal of the person in the Department of Administration who performs audit functions could be delegated to an appropriate county official such as the county administrative services coordinator or the head of the Department of Administration and (b) the statutory duties assigned by the Legislature to the county clerk under Wis. Stat. ch. 70 may not be transferred to the county auditor or another appropriate county official in lieu of the county auditor, but supervisory authority over the manner in which such duties are exercised may be granted to the county auditor or another appropriate county official in lieu of the county auditor. Sincerely,
J.B. Van Hollen
Attorney General
JBVH:FTC:cla
/misc/oag/recent/oag6_08
true
oag
/misc/oag/recent/oag6_08/_138
section
true
