PROPOSED ORDER OF THE WISCONSIN
DEPARTMENT OF WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT
ADOPTING RULES
The Wisconsin department of workforce development proposes the following order to repeal DWD 75.03 (4) and 75.04 ; to renumber and amend DWD 75.19 (2) ; to amend DWD 75.01, 75.02, 75.03 (3), (8), (9), (10) to (16), (17), 75.04, 75.05 (1), (2) and (note), 75.06, 75.07, 75.08 (intro.) and (1) to (5), 75.09 (1) to (3), 75.10 (1) and (2), 75.11, 75.12 (intro.), (1) and (3), 75.13 (1) and (3), 75.14 (title), (1) (intro.), (2) and (3), 75.16 (1), (3) to (5), (6) (a) and (b), (7), (8) (b), (9), (14) (a) and (b), and (15) to (17), 75.17, 75.18, and 75.19 (title), (1) and (2) (title), and (3) to (5) ; and to create DWD 75.03 (2m), (3m), (5r), (9r), and (16m), 75.16 (6) (a) (note) and (b) (note), and 75.19 (2) (b) and (c); relating to appeal procedures for vocational rehabilitation services.
Analysis Prepared by the Department of
Workforce Development
Statutes interpreted
Statutes Interpreted: Section 47.02, Stats.
Statutory authority
Statutory Authority: Section 47.02 (5), Stats.
Explanation of statutory authority
Chapter 47, Stats., governs the vocational rehabilitation program and adopts methods of administering the vocational rehabilitation program to maximize federal participation. Under s. 47.02 (5), Stats., any person aggrieved by a determination of eligibility or ineligibility for vocational rehabilitation services, or by the furnishing or denial of vocational rehabilitation services, may commence an appeal as provided under the rules promulgated by the department.
Related statutes or rules
Wisconsin statutes and rules relating to the appeal procedures for vocational rehabilitation services are set forth in ch. 47, Stats., and ch. DWD 75, Wis. Admin. Code.
Plain language analysis
The proposed rule will do all of the following:
Definitions and Terms
Representative of an Applicant or Eligible Individual
The proposed rule clarifies that a representative of an applicant or eligible individual may invoke the provisions under this chapter.
Right to a Hearing
Under s. DWD 75.04 an individual may appeal a decision concerning eligibility for services or the furnishing or denial of services. The proposed rules clarifies an applicant or eligible individual, or the representative of the applicant or eligible individual, may appeal a determination of ineligibility for services or the decision of furnishing or denial of services whenever vocational rehabilitation services for an individual are denied, reduced, suspended or terminated.
Requesting a Hearing
The proposed rule clarifies, but does not change the time limits for requesting a hearing. The rule clarifies a request for hearing must be filed within 12 months after a determination of ineligibility for services or the decision of the furnishing or denial or services was mailed to the applicant or eligible individual, or the representative of the applicant or eligible individual.
The proposed rule updates the requirements for filing a written hearing request and requires the applicant or eligible individual, or representative of the applicant or eligible individual, to state the issues involved in the appeal and the desired outcome on a form provided by the department.
Time Limit for Holding a Hearing
Under s. DWD 75.07 a hearing shall be held within 45 days of the receipt of the hearing request. The proposed rule changes, from 45 days to 60 days, the time period in which a hearing must be held within receipt of a hearing request.
Filing Motions Relative to a Hearing
Under s. DWD 75.08 (5), a motion for a substitute hearing officer shall be filed with the hearing coordinator and the hearing coordinator forwards the request with their recommendation to the administrator with a copy of any relevant comments regarding that hearing officer's performance. If the motion is granted, the hearing coordinator assigns a different hearing officer. The proposed rule repeals this portion of the rule and requires a motion for a substitute hearing officer be filed with the hearing officer.
In addition, the proposed rule clarifies, but does not change, current rules related to the hearing coordinator acknowledging a hearing request.
Services While a Hearing Officer's Decision is Pending
Under s. DWD 75.11, the department may not suspend, reduce or terminate vocational rehabilitation services pending the decision of a hearing officer unless the services were obtained through fraud, misrepresentation, collusion or criminal conduct. The proposed rule expands this section to include that the department may not suspend, reduce or terminate vocational rehabilitation services pending the decision of a hearing officer unless requested by the applicant or eligible individual, or the representative of the applicant or individual
Recording a Hearing and Transcripts of Hearings
Under s. DWD 75.16 (6), a hearing officer is required to tape record each hearing. The proposed rule eliminates that the method of recording be specifically by tape recording and creates a note with information on how to obtain a copy of the recorded hearing.
The proposed rule also provides that a party may file a written request for a copy of the record in an alternate format if the free copy of the recording cannot be used by a party due to a disability. A note was created with information on how to file a written request of the hearing record.
Hearing Officer's Decision
Section DWD 75.17 is updated to clarify the hearing officer shall issue a written decision within 10 calendar days of a motion and within 30 calendar days of a hearing. The decision shall also state the decision is final unless the applicant or eligible individual, or representative of the applicant or eligible individual, requests a review of the decision within 20 calendar days after the decision was issued. The proposed rule also directs the hearing officer to send a copy of the notice to the administrator's representative and to the hearing coordinator for placement in the applicant or eligible individual's case record.
Review and Modification of the Hearing Officer's Decision
Section DWD 75.19 (1) clarifies that the hearing officer's decision is the department's final decision unless any party decides to initiate a review.
Under current rule, authority for modifying the decision of a hearing officer is conducted by the division administrator. The proposed rule requires the authority for modifying the hearing officer decision be conducted by the department secretary or the secretary's authorized designee. The proposed rule also provides that the division administrator conduct an initial review of the decision and submit a proposed review decision to the secretary or the secretary's designee for consideration. The secretary or secretary's designee will then conduct a review of the decision, the administrator's proposed review decision and issue a final review decision.
Technical Changes
· Modifies current notes to reflect the department's website address and includes a toll-free telephone number.
· Makes minor organizational, drafting and terminology changes.
· Corrects erroneous cross-references to federal and state laws.
Summary of, and comparison with, existing or proposed federal statutes and regulations
Under 29 USC 722 (c), each state is required to establish procedures for mediation of, and procedures for review through an impartial due process hearing of determinations made by personnel of the designated State unit that affect the provision of vocational rehabilitation services to applicants or eligible individuals.
Under 34 CFR part 361, general guidelines and procedures for the review of determinations made by designated State unit personnel are provided in full detail.
The Federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (Act) as amended, is a federal law designed to protect individuals with disabilities and prohibits discrimination on the basis of disability in programs and activities that receive federal financial assistance.
Comparison with rules in adjacent states
Federal law requires all states to develop and implement procedures to ensure that an applicant or eligible individual who is dissatisfied with any determination that affects the provision of vocational rehabilitation services may request, or, if appropriate, may request through the individual's representative, a timely review of that determination. All surrounding states are implementing federal requirements and therefore are similar to Wisconsin rules.
Summary of factual data and analytical methodologies
Proposed rule changes were developed after reviewing state statute and federal regulations.
Analysis and supporting documents used to determine effect on small business or in preparation of the economic impact analysis
The proposed rule does not have an economic impact on small businesses as defined in s. 227.114 (1), Stats., and no analysis is required. The department will post the proposed rule online for 14 days to solicit public comment on the economic impact.
Effect on small business
The proposed rule does not have an effect on small business.
Agency contact person
Kathleen Enders, Program and Policy Analyst
Department of Workforce Development
Division of Vocational Rehabilitation
P. O. Box 7852
Madison, WI 53707-7852
Telephone: (414) 750-0268
Email: kathleen.Enders@dwd.wisconsin.gov
Place where comments are to be submitted and deadline for submission
Kathleen Enders, Program and Policy Analyst
Department of Workforce Development
Division of Vocational Rehabilitation
P. O. Box 7852
Madison, WI 53707-7852
Telephone: (414) 750-0268
Email: kathleen.Enders@dwd.wisconsin.gov
The department anticipates holding a public hearing on September 2, 2015. The department will accept public comments until September 4, 2015.
Section 1. DWD 75.01 is amended to read:
DWD 75.01 Authority
and purpose. This chapter is promulgated under the authority of ss.
47.02(5) and 227.11(2)(a) 103.055 (1), Stats., and in conformity
with requirements under 29 USC 711 (c) and 722(d) 722 (c), and 34
CFR 361.48 361.57, to establish develop and implement procedures
for an applicant or eligible individual appealing decisions the
determination of ineligibility for services or the decision of the furnishing
or denial of services issued by the department’s division of vocational
rehabilitation concerning eligibility for services or the furnishing or
denial of services under the rehabilitation act of 1973, as amended.
Section 2. DWD 75.02 is amended to read:
DWD 75.02
Applicability. This chapter applies to the department, to
applicants for and recipients of services under the act , eligible
individuals, and representatives for the applicants or eligible individuals who
wish to appeal decisions the determination of ineligibility for
services or the decision of the furnishing or denial of services issued
by the department’s division of vocational rehabilitation concerning
eligibility for or the furnishing or denial of services under the act, and
to hearing officers appointed assigned to hear the appeals.
Section 3. DWD 75.03 (2m) is created to read:
DWD 75.03 (2m) “Administrator's representative” means an employee of the department designated by the administrator to represent the department at each hearing.
Section 4. DWD 75.03 (3) is amended to read:
DWD 75.03 (3) “Appeal”
means a request for relief filed with the division based a on the
determination of ineligibility of services or the decision of the
furnishing or denial of services issued by the division relating to
eligibility for services or the furnishing or denial of services under the act.
Section 5. DWD 75.03 (3m) is created to read:
DWD 75.03 (3m) "Contract administrator" means an employee of the department responsible for monitoring the contracts with the hearing officer.
Section 6. DWD 75.03 (4) is repealed.
Section 7. DWD 75.03 (5r) is created to read:
DWD 75.03 (5r) “Determination of ineligibility” means an individual who applies for vocational rehabilitation services and is determined not to be eligible for the services; or an eligible individual receiving services under an IPE and is determined to no longer be eligible for services.
Section 8. DWD 75.03 (8) and (9) are amended to read:
DWD 75.03 (8) “Hearing” means a formal review by an
impartial hearing officer of a the determination of ineligibility
for services or the decision of the division the furnishing or
denial of services issued by an impartial hearing officer the
division.
(9) “Hearing
coordinator” means the person an employee of the department within
the division who maintains the records of hearings under the act,
contacts hearing officers to initiate schedule hearings and
ensures that required time limits requirements for the completion
and reporting of hearings are observed.
Section 9. DWD 75.03 (9r) is created to read:
DWD 75.03 (9r) "Hearing officer" includes an administrative law judge.
Section 10. DWD 75.03 (10) to (16) are amended to read:
DWD 75.03 (10) “Hearing
request” means a written request for a hearing signed by an appellant applicant
or eligible individual, or an appellant’s the representative of
the applicant or eligible individual, which states the issue involved in
the appeal and the desired outcome.
(11) “Intent
to review” means that the administrator department will
review the decision of a hearing officer to determine if the decision will be
allowed to stand or will be modified as provided by the act.
(12) “IWRP” “IPE”
means individualized written rehabilitation program plan for
employment.
(13) “Order
of selection” has the meaning prescribed in s. DWD 65.03 (17) means
the order of priority for service, by category, required by 29 USC 721 (a) (5)
(A) to ensure that clients with the most severe functional limitations who need
multiple services over an extended period of time are served before clients who
have less severe functional limitations or do not require multiple services
over an extended period of time.
(14) “Party”
means the appellant or appellant’s an applicant or eligible
individual, or the representative of the applicant or eligible
individual, or the administrator’s representative.
(15) “Prehearing
interview conference” means a joint face-to-face meeting, a
telephone conference, separate meetings or separate telephone calls by the
hearing officer with the parties prior to the hearing to formulate a statement
of the issue or issues presented by an appeal, to identify
potential witnesses, to establish a schedule for discovery and deadlines
for exchange of witness lists and exhibits, to receive motions and to
clarify any remaining issues to be considered or excluded from a hearing.
(16) “Representative”
means any representative chosen by an applicant or eligible individual, as
appropriate, including a parent or, guardian of an
appellant under age 18, a person designated in writing by an adult appellant as
the , other family member or advocate, unless a representative, a
person has been appointed by a court to represent an appellant or
the person designated by the administrator as his or her the
individual, in which case the court-appointed representative for a
hearing is the individual's representative.
Section 11. DWD 75.03 (16m) is created to read:
DWD 75.03 (16m) "Secretary" means the secretary of the department.
Section 12. DWD 75.03 (17) is amended to read:
DWD 75.03 (17) “Wisconsin
client assistance program” or “client assistance program” means a
service program established by the governor under 34 CFR 370.2 (a) to (d) and
funded in whole or in part by the act to assist individuals with
disability-related issues and appeals under the act.
Section 13. DWD 75.04 is amended to read:
DWD 75.04 Right
to a hearing. An applicant or eligible individual, or a
the representative of an applicant or eligible individual,
may appeal a determination of ineligibility for services or the decision
concerning eligibility for services or of the furnishing or
denial of services under the act, including a decision relating to an
order of selection for services, whenever vocational rehabilitation services
for an individual are denied, reduced, suspended, or terminated.
Section 14. DWD 75.05 (1), (2) and (Note) are amended to read:
DWD 75.05 (1) Time limits. The time limit for filing
a hearing request shall be within 12 months after a determination of
ineligibility for services or the notice of a decision or
action of the furnishing or denial of services was mailed to the appellant
applicant or eligible individual, or the representative of the applicant or eligible
individual. Failure to file a hearing request within the 12 month
limit shall be cause for the hearing request to be dismissed.
(2) How to file. A An applicant
or eligible individual, or the representative of the applicant or eligible individual,
shall file a written hearing request shall be filed and state the
issues involved in the appeal and the desired outcome on a form provided by the
department with the hearing coordinator.
Note: The address for requesting To
obtain a hearing is request form, or for questions relating to
filing a hearing request, contact the Hearing Coordinator, Division of
Vocational Rehabilitation, P.O. Box 7852, Madison, Wisconsin 53707,
telephone (800) 442-3477 or access the form online at http://dwd.wisconsin.gov/dvr/.
Section 15. DWD 75.06 is amended to read:
DWD 75.06 Acknowledgment
of a hearing request. The hearing coordinator shall acknowledge receipt
of a hearing request and notify the parties when a hearing request has
been properly filed within 5 working days after receiving the request. If a
representative has been designated, the notice shall be sent to hearing
coordinator shall notify the applicant's or eligible individual's representative.
If the appellant has a representative, a copy shall also be sent to the
appellant by certified mail. This notice The acknowledgment of a
hearing request shall include as enclosures a copy of this chapter, a
brochure explaining the and information on appeal process rights
and a the Wisconsin client assistance program brochure.
Section 16. DWD 75.07 is amended to read:
DWD 75.07
Time limit for hearing. A hearing shall be held within 45 60 days
of the receipt of the hearing request by a the hearing
coordinator unless the hearing officer grants an extension for good cause at
the request of either party.
Section 17. DWD 75.08 (intro.) and (1) to (5) are amended to read:
DWD 75.08 (intro.) Motions
relative to a hearing. Motions shall be filed by the parties in writing
as soon as possible and are expected at least within 5 working
days prior to a scheduled hearing. A motion shall state the grounds of
the motion and the relief or order requested. Briefs, affidavits, documentary
evidence and other papers in support of a motion shall be filed with the
motion. The Motions shall be filed with the hearing officer and may
include any of the following are examples of common motions but motions
are not limited to these examples:
(1) Motion to extend time limits. A motion
to extend any time limit, including the 45 60-day time limit for
holding a hearing shall be filed with the hearing officer.
(2) Motion to dismiss a hearing request for lack of
subject matter jurisdiction. A motion to dismiss a hearing request on
the grounds that the division department does not have subject
matter jurisdiction may be filed at any time with the hearing officer.
(3) Motion to amend a hearing request. A
motion to expand or restrict the nature or scope of the hearing shall be
filed with the hearing officer.
(4) Motion to withdraw a hearing request.
An appellant applicant or eligible individual, or the representative
of the applicant or eligible individual, may withdraw from the appeal
process at any time. If the appellant applicant or eligible
individual or the representative of the applicant or eligible individual, has
made a verbal request to withdraw and a motion has not been filed with the hearing
officer within 10 calendar days, the hearing officer shall act on the
verbal request and issue a decision.
(5) Motion for a substitute hearing officer.
Either party may file a motion for a substitute hearing officer for reasons of
conflict of interest, bias or qualifications. A motion for a substitute
hearing officer shall be filed with the hearing coordinator. The hearing
coordinator shall immediately forward the request with his or her
recommendation to the administrator with a copy of any relevant comments
regarding that hearing officer’s performance. If the motion is granted, the
hearing coordinator shall assign a different hearing officer. The hearing
coordinator shall forward a copy of any administrator’s comments regarding the
performance of that hearing officer to the division contract administrator as
comments on hearing officer’s performance under a contract.
Section 18. DWD 75.09 (1) to (3) are amended to read:
DWD 75.09 (1) Administrator’s representative. The
administrator shall designate a representative An administrator's
representative shall be designated for each hearing.
(2) Appellant’s representative Representative of applicant or eligible
individual.
Designation of a representative is optional for the appellant applicant
or eligible individual. An appellant applicant or eligible
individual may select any responsible adult as a representative or, as
permitted under federal law, an appellant applicant or eligible
individual may ask the Wisconsin client assistance program to provide
assistance in resolving the disagreement, including preparing the hearing
request for a hearing or serving as the appellant’s representative
of the applicant or eligible individual.
(3) Notice of representation. Notice of
representation shall be filed with the hearing officer as part of the
prehearing interview conference under s. DWD 75.14, or at
least within 5 working days in advance of the scheduled hearing. If an
appellant’s the representative of the applicant or eligible individual
has been properly designated prior to a hearing request, that designation shall
be valid for a hearing unless revoked by the appellant applicant or
eligible individual. If the appellant applicant or eligible
individual is not present at a hearing to introduce a representative, the
hearing officer may require the representative to present identification before
the hearing may proceed.
Section 19. DWD 75.10 (1) and (2) are amended to read:
DWD 75.10 (1) Documents filed with representative. If
a party the applicant or eligible individual has designated a
representative, all correspondence and other documents related to the hearing
shall be mailed to the representative of the applicant or eligible individual.
For documents sent by mail, the date the document is received by the addressee
named in this chapter applicant or eligible individual, or
representative of the applicant or eligible individual, determines the date
of filing.
(2) Filing in person. For papers filed in
person, the date the addressee named in this chapter applicant or
eligible individual, or the representative of the applicant or eligible individual,
receives the document determines the filing date.
Section 20. DWD 75.11 is amended to read:
DWD 75.11 Services
while a hearing officer’s decision is pending. Pending the decision of a
hearing officer, the department may not suspend, reduce or terminate vocational
rehabilitation services including evaluation and assessment services
under an IWRP IPE unless the services were obtained through
misrepresentation, fraud, collusion or criminal conduct, or unless requested
by the applicant or eligible individual, or the representative of the applicant
or eligible individual.
Section 21. DWD 75.12 (intro.), (1) and (3) are amended to read:
DWD 75.12 (intro.) Hearing
officer qualifications. A hearing officer shall be knowledgeable
about impartial and have knowledge of the delivery of vocational
rehabilitation services, the requirements of the state plan for services
under the act, the rules federal and state regulations governing
the provision of the services and the procedures for conducting an impartial
hearing, but may . All of the following shall apply and the hearing
officer shall not:
(1) Be
an employe employee of the division department or
other public agency involved in any decision about furnishing or denying
vocational rehabilitation services except as an administrative law judge, a
hearing examiner or an employe employee of an institution of
higher education. An individual is not considered an employe employee
of the division department solely because the individual is
paid by the division department to serve as a hearing officer.
(3)
Have been previously involved in previous decisions regarding the
vocational rehabilitation of the appellant applicant or eligible
individual.
Section 22. DWD 75.13 (1) and (3) are amended to read:
DWD 75.13 (1) The
hearing officer shall conduct a prehearing interview, conference with
the parties as specified under s. DWD 75.14. The hearing officer may
receive and act on motions under s. DWD 75.08, may use the power of
subpoena under s. 885.01, Stats., and may contact any party prior to a
scheduled hearing to obtain needed information or to suggest mediation
if the parties agree that agreement is possible prior to the hearing. The
parties retain all rights under this chapter regardless of their participation
or nonparticipation in mediation.
(3) The
Except as provided under s. DWD 75.19, the decision of the hearing
officer is final except when the administrator acts under s. DWD 75.19 to
change the decision.
Section 23. DWD 75.14 (title), (1) (intro.), (2) and (3) are amended to read:
DWD 75.14 (title)
Prehearing interview conference.
(1) Purpose. The hearing officer shall ask
the parties to participate in a prehearing interview conference to
do one or more of the following:
(2) Participation. The administrator’s
representative shall participate in the prehearing interview
conference. If the appellant applicant or eligible individual, or
the representative of the applicant or eligible individual, fails to
participate in a prehearing interview conference without prior
notice, the hearing officer shall continue the prehearing interview conference
period for 5 working days. During this period the appellant applicant
or eligible individual, or the representative of the applicant or eligible
individual, may file a good cause explanation and request that the
prehearing interview conference be rescheduled. If a motion is
not filed within 5 working days, the hearing officer shall schedule the hearing
within the 4560-day limit and notify the parties and the hearing
coordinator of this decision. The administrator department may
review this decision as provided in s. DWD 75.19.
(3) Hearing not delayed by participation in a
prehearing interview conference. Participation in a
prehearing interview conference shall not delay a hearing and
does not affect time limits under this chapter. The parties shall not forfeit
any rights under this chapter by participating in a prehearing interview
conference or meeting to reach agreement prior to a hearing.
Section 24. DWD 75.16 (1), (3) to (5), and (6) (a) are amended to read:
DWD 75.16 (1) Hearing is closed. A hearing shall be
closed to the public as a confidential matter under the act unless the appellant
applicant or eligible individual, or the representative of the applicant or eligible
individual files a motion to open the hearing at least within 5
working days in advance of the scheduled hearing.
(3) Attendance at a hearing. Parties and
witnesses shall attend a scheduled hearing unless a motion has been filed with
the hearing officer at least within 5 working days prior
to the a scheduled hearing stating reasonable cause for an
individual to participate in the hearing by a live, real time electronic means
as an alternative to a appearing in person. The hearing officer may grant the
request if the other party has no objection.
(4) Testimony by witnesses. Witnesses may
testify in person by answering questions posed to them, in narrative form, or
by deposition provided that the witness agrees in advance, as part of the
deposition, to permit the recording of the testimony and any subsequent
cross-examination and the witness understands that he or she may be
subpoenaed a subpoena to appear may be issued by the hearing
officer based on the information in the deposition. Requests for testimony by
witnesses by deposition or electronic means shall be filed with the hearing
officer at least within 5 working days prior the to
a scheduled hearing date. The hearing officer may grant the request
if the other party does not object provided that the witness agrees in advance,
and on the record, to permit the recording of his or her
the witness's telephone testimony and any subsequent cross-examination.
(5) Identification of witnesses and exhibits.
Each party shall file lists a list of witnesses and copies
submit a copy of exhibits not previously identified in the prehearing
conference with the hearing officer and the other party at least within
5 working days prior to a scheduled hearing.
(6) (a)
Tape recording Recording. The hearing officer shall
record the each hearing on tape. The appellant applicant
or eligible individual, or the representative of the applicant or eligible individual,
may obtain one free copy of the tape from recording by contacting the
hearing coordinator. No other tape recording of the hearing is permitted.
Section 25. DWD 75.16 (6) (a) (Note) is created to read:
Note: To obtain a copy of the recorded hearing, contact the Hearing Coordinator, Division of Vocational Rehabilitation, P.O. Box 7852, Madison, Wisconsin 53707 or telephone (800) 442-3477.
Section 26. DWD 75.16 (6) (b) is amended to read:
DWD 75.16 (6) (b) Transcript.
Transcripts of the hearing record may be provided at the expense of the
requestor. However, a party who cannot, due to a disability, use the free copy
of the tape recording provided in s. DWD 75.17 may file a written
request with the hearing coordinator for a copy of the record in a different
media an alternate format as a reasonable accommodation.
Section 27. DWD 75.16 (6) (b) (Note) is created to read:
Note: To file a written request for a transcript of the hearing record, contact the Hearing Coordinator, Division of Vocational Rehabilitation, P.O. Box 7852, Madison, Wisconsin 53707 or telephone (800) 442-3477.
Section 28. DWD 75.16 (7), (8) (b), (9), (14) (a) and (b), and (15) to (17) are amended to read:
DWD 75.16 (7) Opening statement by hearing officer.
The hearing officer shall open the hearing with a brief statement of the date,
the location of the hearing, the issues, the parties directly involved in the
hearing and the standard procedures, and shall remind all participants parties
and witnesses present that all personally identifiable information made
available for the hearing is confidential.
(8) (b)
If either party fails to appear at a hearing without prior notice, the hearing
officer shall immediately reschedule the hearing to a date at least within
5 working days after the current date to allow the absent party to explain
the absence. The hearing officer shall notify the parties and the hearing
coordinator by certified mail of the new hearing date and the reason for
rescheduling the hearing. If the appellant applicant or eligible
individual, or the representative of the applicant or eligible individual, fails
to appear at the rescheduled hearing, the hearing officer shall dismiss the
appeal. This dismissal shall not be construed as violation of the 45 60-day
limit for holding a hearing since the hearing was scheduled and held but the appellant
applicant or eligible individual, or the representative of the applicant or eligible
individual, did not appear to present his or her arguments
testimony or evidence. The administrator department may
review this decision as provided in s. DWD 75.19.
(9) Admissibility of evidence or testimony.
At the request of either party, the hearing officer may exclude testimony or
evidence. The hearing officer may also exclude immaterial, irrelevant or unduly
repetitious testimony. A decision to exclude evidence or testimony shall be
made on the record and shall include the rationale and arguments used by the
hearing officer to exclude the material. The hearing officer may issue reserved
rulings on evidence and determine, before the close of the hearing, if the
material will be considered in his or her the decision.
(14)
(a) The hearing officer shall ask the appellant applicant or
eligible individual, or the representative of the applicant or eligible individual,
to make the first presentation and to question the administrator’s representative
and witnesses.
(b) The hearing officer
shall ask the administrator’s designee representative to make the
second presentation and to question the appellant applicant or
eligible individual, or the representative of the applicant or eligible individual,
and witnesses.
(15) Rebuttal and questions. The hearing
officer shall give the appellant applicant or eligible individual. or
the representative of the applicant or eligible individual, the opportunity
to make a rebuttal of evidence presented at the hearing and to question the
administrator’s representative and witnesses and then give the same opportunity
to the administrator’s representative.
(16) Closing arguments. The hearing officer shall
ask the administrator’s representative to present closing arguments. than
and then ask the appellant applicant or eligible individual,
or the representative of the applicant or eligible individual, to present
closing arguments. Closing arguments may be submitted both as verbal arguments
and as written briefs.
(17) Ending the hearing. The hearing officer
shall inform the parties that a written decision will be sent to them by
certified mail within 30 working calendar days after the date of
the hearing and state the date and time at in which the
hearing was closed.
Section 29. DWD 75.17 is amended to read:
DWD 75.17 Notice
of hearing officer’s decision Decision of the hearing officer.
The hearing officer shall issue a written decision within 10 calendar days
of a written motion under s. DWD 75.08 and within 30 calendar days
of a hearing. The hearing officer shall provide a report of the hearing
including the findings and the grounds for the decision. This The decision
notice shall state that the decision is final unless the
administrator acts under s. DWD 75.19 to change the decision administrator's
representative, applicant or eligible individual, or the representative of the
applicant or eligible individual, requests a review of the decision of the
hearing officer within 20 calendar days after the decision is issued, under s.
DWD 75.19, or the appellant, under s. 227.53, Stats., applicant
or eligible individual, or the representative of the applicant or eligible individual,
chooses to petition the circuit court under s. 227.53, Stats. The notice
shall specify the procedures for filing a claim in circuit court. The hearing
officer shall send the original to the appellant applicant or
eligible individual, or the representative of the applicant or eligible individual,
and send copies a copy of the notice to the administrator’s
representative, to the division office of record and to the hearing
coordinator for placement in the appellant's applicant's or eligible
individual's case record and to the hearing coordinator.
Section 30. DWD 75.18 is amended to read:
DWD 75.18
Hearing officer’s report. The hearing officer shall forward the tape
recording of the hearing, a written summary of the hearing and any other
items specified by contract to the hearing coordinator. The hearing
coordinator shall ensure that all required materials have been received and
shall forward the materials to the administrator department for a
decision as to whether a formal review of the hearing officer’s decision is
needed.
Section 31. DWD 75.19 (title) and (1) are amended to read:
DWD 75.19 (title)
Administrator’s review Review of hearing officer’s decision.
(1)
Notice of intent to review. The
hearing officer's decision shall be the department's final decision unless any
party decides to initiate a review. If the administrator department
decides to initiate a review of the hearing officer’s
decision, written notice of this decision shall be filed with the parties by
certified mail within 20 calendar days of the date that the decision of
the hearing officer was mailed. The intent to review notice shall advise the
parties that additional evidence and information relevant to the final decision
may be filed with the administrator not later than department within 30
calendar days following the date of the intent to review notice and that
the administrator department may also collect new evidence from
other sources during that period.
Section 32. DWD 75.19 (2) (title) is amended to read:
DWD 75.19 (2) (title) No delegation of administrator’s authority Review procedure.
Section 33. DWD 75.19 (2) is renumbered DWD 75.19 (2) (a) and amended to read:
DWD
75.19 (2) (a) Authority for modifying the decision of a hearing
officer under this chapter is reserved to the administrator department
secretary or the secretary's authorized designee and may not be otherwise
delegated.
Section 34. DWD 75.19 (2) (b) and (c) are created to read:
DWD 75.19 (2) (b) The administrator shall conduct an initial review of the hearing officer's decision and shall submit a proposed review decision to the secretary or the secretary's authorized designee.
(c) The secretary or the secretary's authorized designee shall conduct a review of the decision of the hearing officer, the administrator's proposed decision under par. (b) and issue a final review decision.
Section 35. DWD 75.19 (3) to (5) are amended to read:
DWD 75.19 (3) Basis for changing hearing officer decision.
The administrator department may not modify a decision of a
hearing officer which supports the position of the appellant applicant
or eligible individual unless, based on clear and convincing evidence, the
decision is clearly contrary to law or federal policy issuances.
(4) Consultation with hearing officer. The administrator
department may consult with the hearing officer regarding the decision.
(5) Notice of outcome of administrator’s the
department's review. The administrator department shall
notify the parties in writing by certified mail of the outcome of the review
within 30 calendar days after the date of the intent-to-review intent
to review notice. The notice shall state the findings, the grounds for the
final decision, that it is the final decision unless modified by a court and information
on how to file a request for circuit court review. The administrator
department shall send copies of the letter and any attachments to the
hearing coordinator for placement in the applicant's or eligible
individual's case record, to the hearing officer and to the division
office of record for placement in the appellant case record contract
administrator.
Section 35. Effective date: This rule shall take effect on the first day of the month following publication in the Wisconsin Administrative Register as provided in s. 227.22 (2) (intro.), Stats.
Dated this ________ day of ________, _________.
WISCONSIN DEPARTMENT OF
WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT
By: _______________________________
Reginald Newson, Secretary
