655.017 Annotation
After January 1, 1991, recovery for loss of society and companionship for death in a medical malpractice case is unlimited; minors may bring separate actions for loss of companionship when malpractice causes a parent's death, including when the decedent is survived by a spouse. Jelinik v. St. Paul Fire & Casualty Ins. Co.
182 Wis. 2d 1,
512 N.W.2d 764 (1994).
655.017 Annotation
Tort Reform: It's Not About Victims. . .It's About Lawyers. Scoptur. Wis. Law. June 1995.
655.019
655.019
Information needed to set fees. The department shall provide the director of state courts, the commissioner and the board of governors with information on hospital bed capacity and occupancy rates as needed to set fees under
s. 655.27 (3) or
655.61.
INSURANCE PROVISIONS
655.23
655.23
Limitations of liability; proof of financial responsibility. 655.23(3)(a)(a) Except as provided in
par. (d), every health care provider either shall insure and keep insured the health care provider's liability by a policy of health care liability insurance issued by an insurer authorized to do business in this state or shall qualify as a self-insurer. Qualification as a self-insurer is subject to conditions established by the commissioner and is valid only when approved by the commissioner. The commissioner may establish conditions that permit a self-insurer to self-insure for claims that are against employees who are health care practitioners and that are not covered by the fund.
655.23(3)(b)
(b) Each insurance company issuing health care liability insurance that meets the requirements of
sub. (4) to any health care provider shall, at the times prescribed by the commissioner, file with the commissioner in a form prescribed by the commissioner a certificate of insurance on behalf of the health care provider upon original issuance and each renewal.
655.23(3)(c)
(c) Each self-insured health care provider furnishing coverage that meets the requirements of
sub. (4) shall, at the times and in the form prescribed by the commissioner, file with the commissioner a certificate of self-insurance and a separate certificate of insurance for each additional health care provider covered by the self-insured plan.
655.23(3)(d)
(d) If a cash or surety bond furnished by a health care provider for the purpose of insuring and keeping insured the health care provider's liability was approved by the commissioner before April 25, 1990,
par. (a) does not apply to the health care provider while the cash or surety bond remains in effect. A cash or surety bond remains in effect unless the commissioner, at the request of the health care provider or the surety, approves its cancellation.
655.23(4)(a)(a) A cash or surety bond under
sub. (3) (d) shall be in amounts of at least $200,000 for each occurrence and $600,000 for all occurrences in any one policy year for occurrences before July 1, 1987, $300,000 for each occurrence and $900,000 for all occurrences in any one policy year for occurrences on or after July 1, 1987, and before July 1, 1988, and $400,000 for each occurrence and $1,000,000 for all occurrences in any one policy year for occurrences on or after July 1, 1988.
655.23(4)(b)1.1. Except as provided in
par. (c), before July 1, 1997, health care liability insurance may have provided either occurrence or claims-made coverage. The limits of liability shall have been as follows:
655.23(4)(b)1.a.
a. For occurrence coverage, at least $200,000 for each occurrence and $600,000 for all occurrences in any one policy year for occurrences before July 1, 1987, $300,000 for each occurrence and $900,000 for all occurrences in any one policy year for occurrences on or after July 1, 1987, and before July 1, 1988, and $400,000 for each occurrence and $1,000,000 for all occurrences in any one policy year for occurrences on or after July 1, 1988, and before July 1, 1997.
655.23(4)(b)1.b.
b. For claims-made coverage, at least $200,000 for each claim arising from an occurrence before July 1, 1987, regardless of when the claim is made, and $600,000 for all claims in any one reporting year for claims made before July 1, 1987, $300,000 for each claim arising from an occurrence on or after July 1, 1987, and before July 1, 1988, regardless of when the claim is made, and $900,000 for all claims in any one reporting year for claims made on or after July 1, 1987, and before July 1, 1988, and $400,000 for each claim arising from an occurrence on or after July 1, 1988, and before July 1, 1997, regardless of when the claim is made, and $1,000,000 for all claims in any one reporting year for claims made on or after July 1, 1988, and before July 1, 1997.
655.23(4)(b)2.
2. Except as provided in
par. (c), on and after July 1, 1997, health care liability insurance may provide either occurrence or claims-made coverage. The limits of liability shall be as follows:
655.23(4)(b)2.a.
a. For occurrence coverage, at least $1,000,000 for each occurrence and $3,000,000 for all occurrences in any one policy year for occurrences on or after July 1, 1997.
655.23(4)(b)2.b.
b. For claims-made coverage, at least $1,000,000 for each claim arising from an occurrence on or after July 1, 1997, and $3,000,000 for all claims in any one reporting year for claims made on or after July 1, 1997.
655.23(4)(c)1.1. Except as provided in
subd. 2., self-insurance shall be in amounts of at least $200,000 for each occurrence and $600,000 for all occurrences in any one policy year for occurrences before July 1, 1987, $300,000 for each occurrence and $900,000 for all occurrences in any one policy year for occurrences on or after July 1, 1987, and before July 1, 1988, $400,000 for each occurrence and $1,000,000 for all occurrences in any one policy year for occurrences on or after July 1, 1988, and before July 1, 1997, and $1,000,000 for each occurrence and $3,000,000 for all occurrences in any one policy year for occurrences on or after July 1, 1997.
655.23(4)(c)2.
2. Notwithstanding
subd. 1., in the discretion of a self-insured health care provider, self-insurance may be in an amount that is less than $1,000,000 but not less than $600,000 for each occurrence on or after July 1, 1997, and before July 1, 1999, and less than $1,000,000 but not less than $800,000 for each occurrence on or after July 1, 1999, and before July 1, 2001.
655.23(4)(d)
(d) The commissioner may promulgate such rules as the commissioner considers necessary for the application of the liability limits under
par. (b) to reporting years following termination of claims-made coverage, including rules that provide for the use of actuarial equivalents.
655.23(5)
(5) While health care liability insurance, self-insurance or a cash or surety bond under
sub. (3) (d) remains in force, the health care provider, the health care provider's estate and those conducting the health care provider's business, including the health care provider's health care liability insurance carrier, are liable for malpractice for no more than the limits expressed in
sub. (4) or the maximum liability limit for which the health care provider is insured, whichever is higher, if the health care provider has met the requirements of this chapter.
655.23(5m)
(5m) The limits set forth in
sub. (4) shall apply to any joint liability of a physician or nurse anesthetist and his or her corporation or partnership under
s. 655.002 (1) (d) or
(e).
655.23(7)
(7) Each health care provider shall comply with this section and with
s. 655.27 (3) (a) before exercising any rights or privileges conferred by his or her health care provider's license. The commissioner shall notify the board that issued the license of a health care provider that has not complied with this section or with
s. 655.27 (3) (a). The board that issued the license may suspend, or refuse to issue or to renew the license of any health care provider violating this section or
s. 655.27 (3) (a).
655.23(8)
(8) No health care provider who retires or ceases operation after July 24, 1975, shall be eligible for the protection provided under this chapter unless proof of financial responsibility for all claims arising out of acts of malpractice occurring after July 24, 1975, is provided to the commissioner in the form prescribed by the commissioner.
655.23 Annotation
That a self-insurance plan could have or should have been approved is irrelevant. Under sub. (3) (a) the plan must actually be approved for a provider to be qualified as a self-insurer. Patients Compensation Fund v. St. Mary's Hospital,
209 Wis. 2d 17,
561 N.W.2d 797 (Ct. App. 1997).
655.23 Annotation
Any liability of a person who is health care provider under ch. 655, while doing a provider's business, is limited to the amount of primary coverage mandated by sub. (4). Since the Fund is obligated to pay any amounts above this limit, the Fund does not have subrogation rights against the non-provider, or his or her insurer. Patients Compensation Fund v. Lutheran Hospital,
223 Wis. 2d 439,
588 N.W.2d 35 (1999).
655.23 Annotation
This section is not preempted by federal law. Opthalmic Mutual Insurance Co. v. Muisser,
143 F.3d 1062 (1998).
655.24
655.24
Insurance policy forms. 655.24(1)
(1) No insurer may enter into or issue any policy of health care liability insurance until its policy form has been submitted to and approved by the commissioner under
s. 631.20 (1) (a). The filing of a policy form by any insurer with the commissioner for approval shall constitute, on the part of the insurer, a conclusive and unqualified acceptance of all provisions of this chapter, and an agreement by it to be bound hereby as to any policy issued by it to any health care provider.
655.24(1m)
(1m) Notwithstanding
sub. (1), the issuance of a policy of health care liability insurance by an insurer to a health care provider constitutes, on the part of the insurer, a conclusive and unqualified acceptance of all of the provisions of this chapter, and an agreement by it to be bound under the provisions of this chapter as to any policy issued by it to a health care provider.
655.24(2)
(2) Every policy issued under this chapter shall be deemed conclusively to provide all of the following:
655.24(2)(a)
(a) That the insurer agrees to pay in full all of the following:
655.24(2)(a)1.
1. Attorney fees and other costs incurred in the settlement or defense of any claims.
655.24(2)(a)2.
2. Any settlement, arbitration award or judgment imposed against the insured under this chapter up to the limits expressed in
s. 655.23 (4), or the maximum liability limit for which the health care provider is insured, whichever is greater.
655.24(2)(a)3.
3. Any portion or all of the interest, as determined by the board of governors, on an amount recovered against the insured under this chapter for which the insured is liable under
s. 807.01 (4),
814.04 (4) or
815.05 (8).
655.24(2)(b)
(b) That any termination of the policy by cancellation or nonrenewal is not effective as to patients claiming against those covered by the policy unless the insured has been notified as provided in
sub. (3) and
s. 631.36, except that an insurer may cancel a health care provider's policy under
s. 631.36 (2) if the health care provider is no longer licensed to practice medicine or nursing.
655.24(3)
(3) A notice of cancellation or nonrenewal that is required under
sub. (2) (b) issued to a health care provider who is a natural person must inform the health care provider that his or her license to practice medicine or nursing may be suspended or not renewed if the health care provider has no insurance or insufficient insurance. The insurer shall retain a copy of each notice issued under
sub. (2) (b) for not less than 10 years from the date of mailing or delivery of the notice and shall furnish a copy to the commissioner upon request.
655.24(4)
(4) The insurer shall, upon termination of a policy of health care liability insurance issued under this chapter by cancellation or nonrenewal, notify the commissioner of the termination.
655.245
655.245
Insurance policy limitations. 655.245(1)
(1) No policy of health care liability insurance may permit a health care provider to reject any settlement agreed upon between the claimant and the insurer.
655.245(2)
(2) A policy of health care liability insurance may permit the insurer to make payments for medical expenses prior to any determination of fault. Such payments are not an admission of fault. Such payments may be deducted from any judgment or arbitration award, but shall not be repaid regardless of the judgment or award. Nothing in this subsection shall restrict the insurer's right of comparative contribution or indemnity in accordance with the laws of this state.
655.25
655.25
Availability and effectiveness for health care liability insurance. No policy of health care liability insurance written under the provisions of
s. 619.04 may be canceled or nonrenewed except for nonpayment of premiums unless the health care provider's license is revoked by the appropriate licensing board. A health care provider whose license is revoked shall be permitted to buy out in cases of a claims-made policy.
655.25 History
History: 1975 c. 37;
1995 a. 85.
655.26
655.26
Reports on claims paid. 655.26(1)
(1) In addition to any information required by the commissioner under
s. 601.42, by the 15th day of each month, each insurer that writes health care liability insurance in this state and each self-insurer approved under
s. 655.23 (3) (a) shall report the following information to the medical examining board and the board of governors on each claim paid during the previous month for damages arising out of the rendering of health care services:
655.26(1)(a)
(a) The name and address of the policyholder or self-insured entity and the name and address of any individual on whose behalf the claim was paid.
655.26(1)(b)
(b) The profession of the individual or the type of facility or entity on whose behalf the claim was paid.
655.26(1)(c)
(c) The health care provider's medical specialty, if the provider is a physician.
655.26(1)(d)
(d) A description of the injury, including its cause and severity.
655.26(1)(e)
(e) Whether the claim was paid as a result of a settlement, a patients compensation panel award or a court award.
655.26(1)(g)
(g) The number and amounts of any previous claims paid by the insurer or self-insurer for damages arising out of the rendering of health care services by the insured, the self-insurer or the employees of the insured or self-insurer. Only claims paid on or after July 20, 1985, are required to be reported under this paragraph.
655.26(1)(h)
(h) Any additional information requested by the medical examining board or the board of governors.
655.26(2)
(2) By the 15th day of each month, the board of governors shall report the information specified in
sub. (1) to the medical examining board for each claim paid by the fund during the previous month for damages arising out of the rendering of health care services by a health care provider or an employee of a health care provider.
655.26(3)
(3) If more than one payment will be made on a claim, the first report filed under
sub. (1) or
(2) after the first payment is made on the claim shall include the total amount of the award or settlement and the projected schedule and amounts of payments.
655.26(4)
(4) Any person who in good faith provides information to the medical examining board or the board of governors under this section is immune from civil liability for his or her acts or omissions in providing such information.
PATIENTS COMPENSATION FUND
655.27
655.27
Patients compensation fund. 655.27(1)
(1)
Fund. There is created a patients compensation fund for the purpose of paying that portion of a medical malpractice claim which is in excess of the limits expressed in
s. 655.23 (4) or the maximum liability limit for which the health care provider is insured, whichever limit is greater, paying future medical expense payments under
s. 655.015 and paying claims under
sub. (1m). The fund shall provide occurrence coverage for claims against health care providers that have complied with this chapter, and against employees of those health care providers, and for reasonable and necessary expenses incurred in payment of claims and fund administrative expenses. The coverage provided by the fund shall begin July 1, 1975. The fund shall not be liable for damages for injury or death caused by an intentional crime, as defined under
s. 939.12, committed by a health care provider or an employee of a health care provider, whether or not the criminal conduct is the basis for a medical malpractice claim.
655.27(1m)(a)(a) The fund shall pay that portion of a claim described in
par. (b) against a health care provider that exceeds the limit expressed in
s. 655.23 (4) or the maximum liability limit for which the health care provider is insured, whichever limit is greater.
655.27(1m)(b)
(b) A health care provider who engages in the activities described in
s. 146.37 (1g) and
(3) shall be liable for not more than the limits expressed under
s. 655.23 (4) or the maximum liability limit for which the health care provider is insured, whichever limit is greater, if he or she is found to be liable under
s. 146.37, and the fund shall pay the excess amount, unless the health care provider is found not to have acted in good faith during those activities and the failure to act in good faith is found by the trier of fact, by clear and convincing evidence, to be both malicious and intentional.
655.27(2)
(2) Fund administration and operation. Management of the fund shall be vested with the board of governors. The commissioner shall either provide staff services necessary for the operation of the fund or, with the approval of the board of governors, contract for all or part of these services. Such a contract is subject to
s. 16.765, but is otherwise exempt from
subch. IV of ch. 16. The commissioner shall adopt rules governing the procedures for creating and implementing these contracts before entering into the contracts. At least annually, the contractor shall report to the commissioner and to the board of governors regarding all expenses incurred and subcontracting arrangements. If the board of governors approves, the contractor may hire legal counsel as needed to provide staff services. The cost of contracting for staff services shall be funded from the appropriation under
s. 20.145 (2) (u).
655.27(3)(a)(a)
Assessment. Each health care provider shall pay an annual assessment, which, subject to
pars. (b) to
(br), shall be based on the following considerations:
655.27(3)(a)1.
1. Past and prospective loss and expense experience in different types of practice.
655.27(3)(a)2.
2. The past and prospective loss and expense experience of the fund.
655.27(3)(a)2m.
2m. The loss and expense experience of the individual health care provider which resulted in the payment of money, from the fund or other sources, for damages arising out of the rendering of medical care by the health care provider or an employee of the health care provider, except that an adjustment to a health care provider's fees may not be made under this subdivision prior to the receipt of the recommendation of the patients compensation fund peer review council under
s. 655.275 (5) (a) and the expiration of the time period provided, under
s. 655.275 (7), for the health care provider to comment or prior to the expiration of the time period under
s. 655.275 (5) (a).
655.27(3)(a)3.
3. Risk factors for persons who are semiretired or part-time professionals.
655.27(3)(a)4.
4. For a health care provider described in
s. 655.002 (1) (d),
(e) or
(f), risk factors and past and prospective loss and expense experience attributable to employees of that health care provider other than employees licensed as a physician or nurse anesthetist.
655.27(3)(am)
(am)
Assessments for peer review council. The fund, a mandatory health care liability risk-sharing plan established under
s. 619.04 and a private health care liability insurer shall be assessed, as appropriate, fees sufficient to cover the costs of the patients compensation fund peer review council, including costs of administration, for reviewing claims paid by the fund, plan and insurer, respectively, under
s. 655.275 (5). The fees shall be set by the commissioner by rule, after approval by the board of governors, and shall be collected by the commissioner for deposit in the fund. The costs of the patients compensation fund peer review council shall be funded from the appropriation under
s. 20.145 (2) (um).
655.27(3)(b)1.1. The commissioner, after approval by the board of governors, shall by rule set the fees under
par. (a). The rule shall provide that fees may be paid annually or in semiannual or quarterly instalments. In addition to the prorated portion of the annual fee, semiannual and quarterly instalments shall include an amount sufficient to cover interest not earned and administrative costs incurred because the fees were not paid on an annual basis. This paragraph does not impose liability on the board of governors for payment of any part of a fund deficit.
655.27(3)(b)2.
2. With respect to fees paid by physicians, the rule shall provide for not more than 4 payment classifications, based upon the amount of surgery performed and the risk of diagnostic and therapeutic services provided or procedures performed.
655.27(3)(b)2m.
2m. In addition to the fees and payment classifications described under
subds. 1. and
2., the commissioner, after approval by the board of governors, may by rule establish a separate payment classification for physicians satisfying
s. 655.002 (1) (b) and a separate fee for nurse anesthetists satisfying
s. 655.002 (1) (b) which take into account the loss experience of health care providers for whom Michigan is a principal place of practice.
655.27(3)(bg)1.1. Every rule under
par. (b) shall provide for an automatic increase in a health care provider's fees, except as provided in
subd. 2., if the loss and expense experience of the fund and other sources with respect to the health care provider or an employee of the health care provider exceeds either a number of claims paid threshold or a dollar volume of claims paid threshold, both as established in the rule. The rule shall specify applicable amounts of increase corresponding to the number of claims paid and the dollar volume of awards in excess of the respective thresholds.
